Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

? asked in Family & RelationshipsFamily · 8 years ago

How Should I tell my parents I'm an atheist?

My parents are both devout Christians, and I was too, for the first 12 years of my life. I'm currently fifteen, and have fully supported atheism (I consider myself a 6 on the Dawkins Scale) for about two years now. I have told everyone that I know personally, at school, or at least they should have no reason to think I'm religious. The only people I haven't told are my parents and my brother, who are all Christians. My parents really want me to go to a "Good, moral, christian college" and I don't. In fact, they have even alluded to the idea that if I was an atheist, or didn't want to go to a christian college, then they wouldn't pay for it. They paid for my brother, but I get way better grades than he did in highschool, yet I could end up having to pay my own tuition if I didn't want four more years of indoctrination. That's right, indoctrination. I feel like that was my entire childhood, being indoctrinated to be a christian. The other day I told my mom that I thought homosexuality was immoral, but that the government shouldn't have any control over the legality of marriage, in that sense at least. I told her that because our country has multiple religions in it, we can't only look to ours for a moral-legislative compass, or to any for that matter. I'd like to mention firstly, this was my own understating of my opinons, I don't have any problem with gays, (I'm not gay though) and I don't see why so many people are against them getting married. I don't think it has any moral strings attached to it. If I had told my mom this, her reaction would be unimaginable. Her reaction to what I actually said (previously mentioned) was "Whoosh.....That's really scary that you even think that it could be ok.... people go to hell for that..." That's what I get to deal with everyday. My mom saying dumb stuff like that, and being ultra-conservative. I honestly don't know how much longer I can go on without suffering a mental breakdown, until I tell them i don't believe in their religion. I've never really had a choice, it was forced on me from birth, and that was that. If I would ever consider myself religious, I would say I'm a Deist (some all-powerful being created the big bang/string theory creation and left the universe to the 4 fundamental forces). Is that better or worse than saying I'm an atheist, to them at least? I'd like to know how other people dealt with this, growing up in a Christian home, super-conservative, and opposed to their ideals. I've gotten over the hump of being outspoken about most of my political views (the exceptions obviously being those that would convict me of atheism) to my parents, and my reasons for objections to theirs. I'm not sure how they view this, whether they like that I'm free-thinking, or that my radically liberal ideals (like equality and freedom!) will send me to hell. Thanks for all the help in advance! Points go to the best answer from a personal story.

Update:

Just to let you guys know, I really want to tell them, I just find it hard to. I feel like a prisoner where the guards don't know I'm captive, but if I try to escape then I get punished. I don't want to be punished, but I do want to tell them. The only reason I still let them drag me to church every sunday is to keep their suspicions away, and to see my friends at church. That's it. Once the sermon starts, I listen for all the factual inaccuracies, and logical fallacies in the speech. That's how I keep myself from flipping out. I also view it as a massive waste of time because I have a ton of homework on the weekend and I would like to not waste upwards of five hours (8AM-1PM) in "sunday clothes" listening to people tell me how to believe what I already don't. The funniest part is, I'm so smart and I know so much about the bible, that pretty much everyone in my church views me as a good person, though very logical and rational, but a good C

10 Answers

Relevance
  • Brian
    Lv 6
    8 years ago

    Well, I'm going to take a slightly different tact.

    Do you want to be a Christian? I bet you've never been exposed to *good* Christian arguments. And the counter arguments to Dawkins - talk about logical fallacies!

    I wrote a book about the origin of mankind from a Christian perspective, and I debate the topic almost every day. I'm certainly not Norm Geisler or Ray Comfort in that I may not convince everyone, but unlike them, I have the time to answer questions. I invite you (and anyone) to ask. Wouldn't it be so much better to tell your parents and brother that you were almost an atheist? What a Christmas present!

    Source(s): http://fromnoahtohercules.com/ - my site email: myname@fromnoahtohercules.com - but swap myname for my name (to avoid spam)
  • 8 years ago

    Well I don't think you are going to change or convince your parents that being atheist is acceptable.

    In a sense you are like a homosexual in a very conservative family. You are the black sheep by not falling in line with the Christian message.

    I would suggest there is nothing to gain from telling your parents. I suspect like a gay child they suspect you are not on the same path as they are. This is going to make them afraid as fear is a large part of many Christian belief systems.

    If you don't want to go to a Christian school and they won't pay for it then I would set out to find ways to fund your education at another college or university. You may be able to find grants...maybe even one for people in just your situation. You may be able to find help at your school guidance counselor for tools and options you may have.

    In the meantime accept your parents for the closed minded homophobic Christians that they are. It is what they think it is the right thing to do. I disagree with them and agree with you but to just fight with them is of no advantage to anyone. Everyone will just dig in their heels and a divide will grow between both sides. What may help is they may be right...may be...or you may be wrong...it is possible. So, because we don't really know until it is too late if there is a heaven or whatever is after death then we may be wrong about what we think. At least one of you is wrong. There can't be a heaven and not be a heaven at the same time. So, one of you is wrong and maybe both.

    The real truth of the things covered by religion may not be accurately understood by anyone now on Earth. There is certainly a lot of space, planets and suns out of our small little world. It is not inconceivable that we think we know but are not correct.

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    First you ought to ascertain no matter if to inform them or no longer. you say your mother and father received't disown you or kick you out, yet keep in mind that some different person ought to do something undesirable to you at the same time as your mother and father spread the interest that their son is an atheist. in case you prefer to inform them, warn them. tell them you've some very undesirable information for them and this is extremely massive. of route they imagine you'll burn for all eternity contained in the "lake of fireplace" because the Quran says of kafirs (infidels) and it really is terrible information for individuals to take heed to about their newborn. So, take that under consideration. Who is often used with? per chance with time, in case your mother and father are not too old or conservative, they're going to come round on your way of questioning, inshallah. :-)

  • Judy H
    Lv 4
    8 years ago

    My Dad kinda did something similar, but without the religious aspect. I was a musical prodigy, but for college he wanted me to go to medical school. I had two years of pre-med, then I took an audition at a music school on a whim and got a full scholarship. Whoopee! I don't know how this relates to you. But it seems you are bright enough to get somebody else to fund your education. Oh, and the pre-med training came in handy - I transcribed medical reports as a part-time living for years cuz it's hard to make a living with music.

  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    I have a cuzin whose parents are pike yours they are devout christians he goes to a christian school where he is currently the only senior at his school lol he always told me he wanted to go to a public school but his parents would not let him , unlike you though he believes in christianity but not to the extent where you believe will go to hell and all that stuff ... He wants out of his house because honestly its hard i been there an mann i wanted out to and i was there for 2days

    There is not much you can do though unless your willing to face their reaction

    My anwser is not much help at all i know

    But i though i would share it with you

  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    Just be respectful and not in their faces about it like Richard Dawkins. I just don't go to church anymore I think my parents get the picture

  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    it's your oppinon, your way of how you live your life. you dont need to tell them tho. you can but at the right time. i never believed in god and flat out told my parents one day and they were upset but i explaned my reason and said sorry i dont have the same outlook as you guys. just do that

  • Sam
    Lv 6
    8 years ago

    Don't tell them until you graduate college.

  • 8 years ago

    I think bad.

  • 2017
    Lv 7
    8 years ago

    so don't tell them, it is really none of their business what you do.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.