Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Mike
Lv 7
Mike asked in Politics & GovernmentPolitics · 8 years ago

Why do cities like Chicago & NY which have very strict gun laws have such violent gun crime rates?

Chicago and New York have also had laws in the past completely banning any kind of carrying of handguns. Concealed or open. I''m a trucker who has been to Chicago and NY many times and have witnessed this first hand.

Every time I went to Chicago, a dozen or so kids would be reported murdered by guns every night This was just in the city of Chicago alone.

Thanks in advance for your answers.

Update:

To you citing population density. Chicago and NY have higher crime rates. A crime rate is calculated per capita. Population density is a cop out answer.

16 Answers

Relevance
  • ?
    Lv 7
    8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Because Flag Spitting Righties travel there.

    ..

    But I hear where you're coming from.

    You Red State Rightie Flag Spitters LOVE to bring up big city gun violence.

    What you always fail to mention though - is most deaths by guns - come at the hands of gun owners - --- either from the Rural Red State, America Hating Right Wing Pricks killing themselves - or Their Children getting their guns and killing the parents - or classmates.

    That's why I don't support Gun Laws - Guns are doing a GREAT job of eliminating Red State Rightie Flag Spitting Morons.

    Thanks!

    I sincerely hope this helps.

  • 5 years ago

    1

    Source(s): Criminal Record Search Database - http://criminalrecords.raiwi.com/?OUYU
  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    You don't know what you are talking about. Chicago has had in increase in gun murders but not New York. There has actually been a drop in the number of murders there. Its murder rate is where it was in 1963. It even made news a couple of weeks ago when one day there wasn't a single reported murder in the city. The cops didn't know what to do with themselves.

  • 8 years ago

    People in Chicago and NY can still buy guns from other parts of the state and country. Good argument for action on the federal level.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Strega
    Lv 7
    8 years ago

    Well, you'd be wrong about NYC. Gun crime has been dropping there consistently since 1990. And most guns that end up in these cities are from other states that have more relaxed gun laws.

    http://www.theatlanticcities.com/neighborhoods/201...

    And if the gun crime in places like Chicago truly bothered you the you would advocate for better education and opportunities for these communities. But I'm guessing you vote republican.

  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    Yeah well go to Oklahoma and justify shooting there, maybe in those cities it has something to do with population density, you think. Not really population density statistics are used to sell guns by manufacturers as well as crime statistics by crimes committed using guns. You need to learn before you cite crime figures.Your rational as well a judgement by a truck driver is the real cop-out!

  • 8 years ago

    As anyone who had any brain at all could have figured out, a person can buy hundreds of assault rifles and other weaponry, and thousands of bullets, from any gun show in most of the country, and DRIVE them to Chicago and NY.

    Of course, that's too complex for a brainless person to grasp.

    If the US didn't manufacture and sell to ANYONE millions of guns, millions of guns wouldn't be available to anyone who wants them.

  • ?
    Lv 7
    8 years ago

    because you can travel 5 minutes and buy a gun right outside the city limits...

    there is no policing of the city limits...

    to ban something that still has easy access doesn't work so well...

    EDIT: national bans work far better in most nations...

  • 8 years ago

    The answer is obvious... Criminals are inherently cowards. They are much more likely to attack people indiscriminately if they know they won't be able to fight back. In concealed carry states, they never know if their intended victim might be "packing" so they think twice about committing a crime.

  • 8 years ago

    People don't understand the concept of the BLACK MARKET. It isn't just for drugs, people get guns either way. And you know what the last society was to ban guns? Germany 1938.

  • jl
    Lv 7
    8 years ago

    common misconception. the violent gun crime rates for the those cities is much lower for the POPULATION. A circle around NYC of 20 miles is about 15million people. Any circle in the midwest of 20mile radius will of course have a lower gun crime rate because its much less populated. However, if you draw a circle around 15 million PEOPLE in the midwest you violent gun crime rates will be much higher.

    edit:

    "Population density is a cop out answer" horse sheet. I'm 10x safer in manhattan than in upstate NY woods. That's not to mention about 80% of the gun crimes in NYC are drug related in back alleys. Not something I have to worry about either.

    State State code "Total

    murders" "Total

    firearms murders, 2011" Total firearms murders, 2010 % change, 2010-11 Firearms murders as % of all murders Firearms murders per 100,000 population Firearms robberies per 100,000 pop) Firearms assaults per 100,000 population

    Maine ME 25 12 11 9 48 0.9 5.8 4.52

    North Dakota ND 12 6 4 50 50 0.93 4.79 4.79

    Illinois IL 452 377 364 4 83 2.93 2.26 5.26

    Vermont VT 8 4 2 100 50 0.75 4.32 12.6

    New Hampshire NH 16 6 5 20 38 0.53 9.83 15.14

    Oregon OR 77 40 36 11 52 1.05 14.57 17.55

    Rhode Island RI 14 5 16 -69 36 0.57 12.71 17.86

    Connecticut CT 128 94 97 -3 73 2.71 34.85 20.06

    New York NY 774 445 517 -14 57 4.12 23.28 20.06

    Wyoming WY 15 11 5 120 73 2.01 3.65 20.44

    South Dakota SD 15 5 8 -38 33 0.68 4.91 20.6

    Utah UT 51 26 22 18 51 0.97 10.98 21.32

    Virginia VA 303 208 250 -17 69 2.58 35.4 21.35

    Iowa IA 44 19 21 -10 43 0.71 7.31 21.95

    Minnesota MN 70 43 53 -19 61 0.82 20.11 22.52

    Idaho ID 32 17 12 42 53 1.14 3.41 23.43

    Kentucky KY 150 100 116 -14 67 2.36 39.77 25.14

    New Jersey NJ 379 269 246 9 71 3.07 49.87 26.94

    Wisconsin WI 135 80 97 -18 59 1.47 43.86 27.4

    Washington WA 161 79 93 -15 49 1.25 20.72 28.44

    Montana MT 18 7 12 -42 39 0.76 3.78 29.03

    Indiana IN 284 183 142 29 64 3.29 53.14 29.91

    Massachusetts MA 183 122 118 3 67 2.02 27.84 33.19

    Nebraska NE 65 42 32 31 65 2.5 25.44 33.84

    Ohio OH 488 344 310 11 70 3.54 65.45 37.97

    Pennsylvania PA 636 470 457 3 74 3.97 54.69 39.44

    Maryland MD 398 272 293 -7 68 4.7 79.71 41.18

    United States United States 12,664 8,583 8,874 -3 68 2.75 39.25 43.77

    California CA 1,790 1,220 1,257 -3 68 3.25 42.97 45.39

    Colorado CO 147 73 65 12 50 1.51 25.74 45.72

    Mississippi MS 187 138 120 15 74 7.46 60.07 51.69

    West Virginia WV 74 43 27 59 58 2.87 16.08 52.04

    Nevada NV 129 75 84 -11 58 3.07 69.77 53.3

    Arizona AZ 339 222 232 -4 65 3.53 50.24 57.36

    Oklahoma OK 204 131 111 18 64 3.64 42.81 58.07

    Texas TX 1,089 699 805 -13 64 2.91 50.21 58.28

    Georgia GA 522 370 376 -2 71 3.93 72.48 58.64

    North Carolina NC 489 335 286 17 69 3.87 48.72 67.44

    Kansas KS 110 73 63 16 66 2.78 24.86 76.87

    Alaska AK 29 16 19 -16 55 2.24 18.19 80.47

    Delaware DE 41 28 38 -26 68 3.09 69.67 81.36

    Michigan MI 613 450 413 9 73 5.06 55.95 86.41

    New Mexico NM 121 60 67 -10 50 2.98 34.96 87.26

    District of Columbia DC 108 77 99 -22 71 12.46 242.56 87.7

    Missouri MO 364 276 321 -14 76 4.64 52.47 88.9

    Louisiana LA 485 402 351 15 83 10.16 63.48 99.51

    Arkansas AR 153 110 93 18 72 4.39 45.45 100.56

    South Carolina SC 319 223 207 8 70 5.41 52.93 127.88

    Tennessee TN 373 244 219 11 65 3.92 72.88 137.58

    Hawaii HI 7 1 7 -86 14 0.07

    https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AonYZ...

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.