$100 for PS3 games, suggestions?

I have Hitman: Absolution, Silent Hill HD, Far Cry 3, Call of Duty BlackOps 2, Fear 3, Uncharted 1,2,3, Dead Space 1-2, Demons Souls, Dark Souls, Infamous 1-2, The Orange Box, Portal 2, Borderlands 2 and Dead Island

Here is what I like:

+ great story (like Half-Life)

+ fun gameplay (like Uncharted)

+ anything that makes a great game

I hate:

- poor level design

- generic feel to stories (like Fear 3)

- mid game drops in plot and gameplay (like resident evil 6)

I was thinking of getting Playstation plus for a year and the getting a game like Heavy Rain or Sleeping Dogs.

Any answers will be appreciated, and if you feel like explaining your answers, that would be awesome.