Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Is it very common for doctors to fail to diagnose an illness?
In August I took my 4 months baby to my local A&E because of difficult in breathing. She was admitted & after 3 days of failing to diagnose, they transfered her to another hospital - it has specialists, there they failed to reach a decision & sent her back to my local. My local doctors started telling me babies breathe like that & tried to discharge her, which I refused insisting they send her to Great Ormond, after 2 weeks we were sent to Great Ormond & they found she had abcess on her throat which was blocking her airways & they operated her & she started breathing normally. I mean how common is this sort of thing?
6 Answers
- PlogstiesLv 78 years agoFavorite Answer
Sadly, it does happen and generally reflects a failure of competence and diagnostic skill(in not recognizing that the child has unusual but significant symptoms). I hope your baby does well.
I could write a book about the faux pa's and fiascos I saw in my thirty one years of practice in internal medicine(much of it hopsital-based), almost always reflecting lack of competence or, at times, pure laziness and lack of thoroughness. Rare conditions, especially (and this applies to your child) often escape notice by any but the most thorough and knowledgable physicians. We as a species are far from perfect and some of us are very far from being so - and our work performance reflects this.
- Anonymous8 years ago
It is not common, but yes it does happen and it will continue to happen in the future. The trouble is that they simply have to make a clinical diagnosis based on the evidence in front of them at the time.
Perhaps in this case the issue was at which point did the abscess become big enough to be visible enough or obstructive enough to be noticeable. Tests would have been done on both the previous admissions and expert witnesses could make a lot of money arguing the points on this one.
You instincts paid off, she is now well and all is well and she is hopefully thriving again and life is moving forward. So enjoy.
- 8 years ago
It is always puzzling, I always feel mothers instinctively know. Symptoms can point to many different things and when symptoms that point to something minor but also something serious, I do feel that necessary tests should be done especially regarding babies and small children who can't let anyone know of their exact symptoms.
When my daughter was little she had meningitis and out GP actually sent me home with calpol, but as a mother I just knew, and took her to A&E she was diagnosed with meningococcal septicimia that night, the pedriatrician took me to one side a few weeks later and said she would not have made it through the night if she had of been left, which infuriated me. I suppose the whole situation has changed me into a very over protective panicky mother that always wants a second or third opinion maybe when it is not always needed.
- 8 years ago
drs practice medicine, its what its called for all of them. if noones dealt with something before they go for what they know to do the best they can. you were right to keep pushing, good girl. its sometimes about insurance coverage that their hands are tied as to what they can do, ask them, is insurance the problem? you can then call your insurance company to see what needs to be done. some insurances dont cover certain things period.yes drs practice to help people but just like u and me wake up and go to work each day ok. hopefull thats the end of the child having problems, happy new years
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- Anonymous8 years ago
NO,it isn't.