Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Deviedra asked in PetsFish · 8 years ago

Aquarium plant advice needed, and is this a good fish stocking idea?

I have a 3ft Juwel tank with the dimensions 36'' x 12'' x 16'' and I am considering my stocking options at the moment. The tank will be at 22 degrees C and at ph 7

I've come up with this one but I want to know if something should be swapped out or what would be better instead of one or more of the fish I've chosen, or if it is over/under stocked

6 rummynose tetras

4 golden barbs

3 sterba's corys

1 albino pleco

What plants should I consider purchasing for these fish?

Update:

@Robert - Ah I forgot those like to consume living plants. Danios sound like a good substitute. What plants should I be looking at then when I make the sub?

Update 2:

@Natural Born Chaos - I have been doing some research, but perhaps not enough as I didn't know Rummy's were that sensitive to stress.

I was planning to add them last and the Pleco second from last (due to their algae eating habits). The website I have been using to look at fish species says that they can live in groups of six or more, and I was thinking 8 at most (the website is: http://fishkeeper.co.uk/site/databank ). I'm not sure what kind of Albino Pleco they have at the store, but the maximum size they grow to is 32cms (they have several fully grown Albinos of the same species in the store). I would be willing to consider a smaller species of Pleco though.

I'm not sure if I could house 5 sterba's with everything else that I have planned without the water quality being poor, unless I go for a smaller species of cory? I will consider loaches instead but it depends on what the store has.

I've switched out the Golden Barbs due to their eating habits and t

Update 3:

@Natural Born Chaos - I have been doing some research, but perhaps not enough as I didn't know Rummy's were that sensitive to stress.

I was planning to add them last and the Pleco second from last (due to their algae eating habits). The website I have been using to look at fish species says that they can live in groups of six or more, and I was thinking 8 at most (the website is: http://fishkeeper.co.uk/site/databank ). I'm not sure what kind of Albino Pleco they have at the store, but the maximum size they grow to is 32cms (they have several fully grown Albinos of the same species in the store). I would be willing to consider a smaller species of Pleco though.

I'm not sure if I could house 5 sterba's with everything else that I have planned without the water quality being poor, unless I go for a smaller species of cory? I will consider loaches instead but it depends on what the store has.

I've switched out the Golden Barbs due to their eating habits and

Update 4:

temperature preference for a species of Danio that will live in the said conditions. The lighting that I have is 2.5W although I could invest in a brighter bulb depending on what lighting conditions the fish prefer.

I'm not looking for a center piece fish really, but I do like the look of Rams.

I'll definitely look into the sites you've suggested though. Thanks for the advice.

4 Answers

Relevance
  • 8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Rummynose tetras are very susceptible to stress, because of this they should be kept in large numbers, usually more than 10, personally, I would have a group of at least 15. Rummynose tetras are also incredibly sensitive to water quality, they should be added last to the aquarium. After it has been running for a minimum time of 12 weeks.

    Gold barbs are more of a subtropical fish and prefer a temperature ranging from 64-75F. Knowing the rummynose tetras require a temperature in the lower 80's, I do not recommend keeping the two together. - Rather than barbs, why not add a centre piece fish? Some great centre piece fish that would work great in your tank are German blue rams and dwarf gourami.

    Corydora's are another schooling fish, they should be kept in a group no less than 5. However, in a tank of that size I would advise having at least 8. - An alternative to cory catfish are loaches, the botia species are great for snail invasions. With planted tanks, you usually get a few snails with them, they multiply and your aquarium will become overgrown with snails. Because of this, I keep a group of loaches in almost all of my planted aquariums, yoyo loaches and dwarf chain loaches are non-aggressive and make great lively additions to aquariums. Of course, if you wanted you could keep a group of each, 5 loaches and 5 cories.

    The lack of species identification for the albino pleco leads me to believe that you're talking about a common. Common plecos get to be around 18", and are definitely not a good choice in tanks under 120 gallons. Instead why not try an albino bristlenose pleco, they only get 5-6" are a great addition to a planted tank. A few other options for algae eaters include 1 rubberlip pleco, 9 oto catfish, 20 amano or cherry shrimp, 6 pitbull plecos, 1 flash pleco, 1 chocolate zebra pleco and 1 butterfly pleco.

    Alright, so now we have some bottom dwelling fish, some mid-dwellers, a centrepiece, and an algae eater. All that's left is a top dwelling fish, to which I would suggest marble, silver or platinum hatchetfish. Hatchet fish are also sensitive to water quality and prefer to be in larger groups, Also add these last and have at least 10 of them.

    Now we've come to plants, this all depends on what kind of lighting you have. For floating plants I would recommend frogbit, some hardy, easy to care for plants include:

    - Willow Leaf Hygrophilla

    - Water Wisteria

    - Small Leafed Hygrophilla

    - Java Moss

    - Anubias

    - Common Sword Plant

    - Ambulia

    - Java Fern

    - Valisneria

    - Banana Plants

    - Hornwart

    - Valisneria

    - Cryptocoryne

    - Christmas Moss

    - Hairgrass

    - Dwarf Hairgrass

    You can use aquarium stock calculations such as http://www.aqadvisor.com/ But please keep in mind that these types of websites should only be used as a guideline and should not be taken too seriously.

    Don't forget to cycle your aquarium first.

    Please see these links;

    http://www.fishyou.com/water.php

    http://www.oscarfishlover.com/how-to-cycle-a-tank/...

    http://theaquariumwiki.com/The_Nitrogen_Cycle

    NOTE: Before buying fish please do the proper research to insure that you are suiting all the fishes needs.

  • 5 years ago

    Cherry Barbs have to be in 20 gallons plus and corporations of 6 plus . The Betta fish is okay ,but i would put off the Barbs and appear at whatever like Dwarf Rasbora and a few Shrimp and three-4 pygmy corys .

  • 8 years ago

    I think your planned water temperature is a little too low.

    By the way, I have a planted tropical community aquarium with exactly the same size.

    36"long x 12" wide x 16" high.

    Check out my setup with videos and full list of items/fish/plants used. It might give you some ideas.

    http://petskeepersguide.com/forums/Thread-Show-off...

  • Robert
    Lv 7
    8 years ago

    Barbs and plants are a bad combination. Barbs eat most plants. If you substitute something for barbs, like danios or Rrasboras, you can keep most types of plants as long as your lighting is sufficient. If your light is less than2 watts per gallon, get Java Fern and Anubias. If you are 2.5 watts per gallon or more, all aquarium plants can grow well.

    Source(s): Robert Price, Phd, Ichthyology The Planted Tank Yamatogreen.com
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.