Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Dale A
Lv 6
Dale A asked in PetsDogs · 8 years ago

Am I getting thumbs down because I'm a vet?

I've been on Yahoo Answers for quite a while now, started when I was in vet school, gave me some good experience answering people's questions in a 'low stress' type of environment. Showed me what was important to owners in the context of my studies.

I'm now graduated, and often on the "Source" of my answer I put "I'm a vet" as the source. I suspect there are people out there who thumbs down when they see that, because they think I'm lying.

So -- would you assume I'm lying and thumbs down me?

Update:

Actually I am a vet (just noticed my profile is out of date... I don't come on here as much as I used to). I graduated a little over a year ago. I can (if challenged) back up the fact that I'm a vet (got to think of a good verification path that I couldn't fake mind you... the old one was so much better but I no longer have my ucalgary email address so the one listed in my profile doesn't work anymore...).

Mind you, the fact that I say "I'm a vet" to me shouldn't be cause for 'thumbs down' I would think more that the content of the message would cause a thumbs down, but I've noticed a distinct change since graduating, and I can only assume that its because people think I'm lying.

Update 2:

Oh, I don't expect 'best answer' always, but I also don't expect to get more thumbs down when I add "I'm a vet" to the end of my posts.

If you'd thumbs down me for saying "I'm a vet" is it because you don't believe I'm a vet? Or is it because you think I'm being arrogant (not sure how stating a fact is being arrogant, but...)

Update 3:

Oh, I don't expect 'best answer' always, but I also don't expect to get more thumbs down when I add "I'm a vet" to the end of my posts.

If you'd thumbs down me for saying "I'm a vet" is it because you don't believe I'm a vet? Or is it because you think I'm being arrogant (not sure how stating a fact is being arrogant, but...)

Update 4:

@hills --- what answers don't you agree with? (Are you thinking about the Tylenol question I just answered? I can provide you with a reference if you'd like).

Update 5:

So --- what would be adequate proof in your mind of the claim? Best I can think of is to post a video somewhere of me with my 'vet stuff' (degrees, textbooks, etc), and in the video mention that I do post on Yahoo Answers, which would cost an awful lot of money to fake, but of course, there could be another "Dale A" who posts on Yahoo Answers, and I might not be him (so still technically possible to fake. I could tell you to contact me on my work email (which has vet in the domain name), but that wouldn't be too hard to fake (anyone can register a domain with "Vet" in the name, and to be honest I don't really feel like giving out my email address on Yahoo answers. I could post a link to me on the AB.VMA's website, but again, doesn't really prove I am who I say I am.

Add to that though, I doubt many who thumbs down the answers really care enough to validate the claim, so I doubt it would be effective.

Update 6:

I guess the problem as I see it, is that people are calling my integrity in to question (using the answers to this question as I guide, I suspect I am getting thumbs down because I tell people I'm a vet), which upsets me, but by the same token I recognize that anyone can say anything they like on the net. I could lie and say I'm an M.D. (could probably fake it fairly well too). I get it, I really do. I'm also a reformed computer geek.

I do feel though that its important to put the qualification on the end of things though, as there are often downright dangerous answers being posted by others and I'd like to *tell* the person asking the question that I actually *do* know what I'm talking about.

Suppose I could reference an actual textbook when I post, but my texts aren't available publicly online, so it wouldn't really help anyone confirm what I'm saying.

22 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    But your not a vet being in your final year does not make you a vet and any one can say anything one here ,its the internet and you could be any one .

    Edit..Many people claim to be vets on here and give dangerous advice ,so look at it from our point of view you could be any one .I only know of one vet that is a knowledge partner on here and has his own practice as he resides in my country

    But TDs do come with the territory on here no matter who you are or say you are.

    Edit..As i said TDs come with the territory i get a lot of TDs and just move on but any one with a genuine problem should call there vet the one they know and trust .

    You need to understand you sit behind a computer screen any one can say there a vet or anything come to think of it .We don't know you ,You could be any one do you get it now .

    Edit..We don't need proof any one with a genuine problem needs to call a vet they use,I also don't understand why a supposed professional would go to the extreme's of trying to prove who they are either .

    It makes no sense to me me .

    Heck i am a qualified professional in my field of expertise but i just answer questions on here i don't need people to know who i am or what i do .Or also post anything other than an answer.

  • 8 years ago

    As the first person said…

    Welcome to the internet.

    People can say what they like, when they like.

    Their answers could be shrouded in truth… or lies.

    If see the words “I am a vet” I automatically roll my eyes and think, here we go…

    But if you give a great answer that I agree with, and you sound professional and articulate, you would still get a TU from me.

    However, most people who claim they are vets on this site, seem to have trouble even spelling the word veterinarian!

    It is amazing to read the hair raising replies all too often given by the so called “experts”, such as:

    “Vetrinariens” (yes I have seen it spelt like that by a “self-proclaimed” vet).

    Animal Behaviourists that don’t know the difference between resource guarding and protecting.

    Professional dog trainers that can only quote TV trainers.

    Professional dog breeders that “bread German Shepards” (yep apparently many cant spell their own breed… or the WORD breed).

    The lists are endless and tiring, and most people know that someone who does not have the basic grasp of grammar or spelling is likely NOT a real vet…

    Even if they claim they are.

    Give clear correct answers, and hopefully people will listen.

    I was a vet nurse – But tend to only sign that at the bottom if it is very relevant to what I wrote.

    9 times out of 10 – I don’t need to mention it.

    As someone else said - drop the "I am a vet" at the end.

    Problem solved.

    Source(s): Life
  • Cheryl
    Lv 7
    8 years ago

    the reality is most people on yahoo answers who claim to be a vet are not ... and sometimes when trolls use the words "i'm a vet" and then answer something idiotic, i will thumb's down ... what vet has time to kill on yahoo answers ??? i can remember many times where someone answering claimed to be a vet and answered the most idiotic things, things a real vet would just not say ... and especially when a real vet could go to any other proper vet site and get paid for their knowledge if they wanted to share their knowledge ... those sites require proof that a person is a vet and charge people to provide advice ... it is just not logical for a true vet to be on yahoo answers ... i don't know about you personally, never heard of you before, but the thumb's down could be a combination of people doubting you are a vet and the answers you are providing ... so why even put that you are a vet ??? saying you are one will make people skip over your answer as people will assume you are just a kid trying to get their answer noticed ... if you provide a good answer and can back it up with something other than "i'm a vet" i think you would not get thumbs downed ... it has nothing to do with integrity, holy moly that is funny, and makes me question even more if you are a vet (and i really don't care if you are or not), yahoo answers is for entertainment purposes only, from little kids to senior citizens, just passing some time ...

  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    Once you come to terms with the fact that this place is an unsalvageable clownshow of ignorance and depravity, it won't bother you so much that people; 1) don't believe you're a vet, 2) TD you for it either way, 3) pick insanely stupid answers over your answer for BA. That's how we roll here in the Y!A

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Kitti
    Lv 5
    8 years ago

    I think it just comes with the territory of posting on here. Maybe they are TDing you because you put that you are a vet. Maybe they don't believe you're a vet. Maybe they simply disagree with your point of view. After all, just like human doctors, different vets can have different opinions and diagnoses.

    I also haven't seen you before (at least not to my knowledge) so I don't get to see all the answers you're giving. If you're giving medical advice for people with sick animals on here, maybe you're getting TDs because you aren't actually examining the animal in question and people don't like it.

    Not that I'm saying you're doing that at all, of course.

    I once had one of my answers reported because I think whoever did it honestly just got butthurt over my answer. I may have been blunt, but I was never insulting or rude, and Y!A admins agreed with me, lol.

  • 8 years ago

    There are people on here that claim they are either vets or vet assistant. We have no way of knowing whether they are aren't and it stands to reason that most vets will not give out free advice. Yes welcome to the board. A lot of people also do not want to hear the truth so they would give thumbs down anyway.

    I get thumbs down all the time and even get blocked because people just don't want to hear the truth and when they do they say we are rude, sarcastic, and numerous other not so nice names. Sorry but I speak my mind and if people don't like it, too bad.

  • 8 years ago

    Don't worry about it. I get TD'ed all the time because I'm a CVT and an old balanced trainer. I give information for free. What people do with it is their business. I do have to say that answering questions on this forum does remind me about the ignorance of many pet owners. If nothing else, I am better able to answer people's questions when at work.

    Oh and let the TD's fly...

  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    Dont care if youre an actual vet or not, i dont know you in person - I flat out REFUSE to accept any medical advice UNLESS it is from my TRUSTED vet whom I actually VISIT and TALK to when my animals are in need of medical help. Plus, if there is something medical related that I am either unsure of or need some guidance until able to get to the vet THEN I will CALL my veterinarian clinic and question them OR an emergency clinic

  • 4 years ago

    The Vietnam conflict became an American tragedy. interior the fullest sense it became a political conflict not as a results of fact of oppression of the aggressor state North Vietnam yet via mismanagement of the U. S. executive previous the beginning up of the Indo-China conflict. Few ever knew that the Viet Minh on the top of the 2nd international conflict became appealling to the U. S. to assist their independence from France as Vietnam became then a French colony. yet as Allied states during the conflict and political concerns the U. S. have disregarded those appeals and paved the beginning up of the IndoChina conflict coming up into the Vietnam conflict. France lost at Dien Bien Phu. leaving a divided usa. at the same time because it is actual that Viet Minh became of course a communist ideology, Why not look at Tito's Yugoslavia who at the same time as being a communist state became not prompted via China nor the U.S. at that element leaving a buffer state for Western international places in Europe. the U. S. became then mired into helping succeeding regimes in Saigon. the would desire to offer men, components, and money into South Vietnam escalated. First there have been in elementary terms volunteers, then as choose for greater men arose, the Draft became invoked. people who fought interior the Vietnam conflict believed they have been combating the unfold of Communism. They gave up jobs, families, existence and limb. Little did they knew that the conflict and all they gave became given away in a small domicile in France. as a results of fact the the Vietnam conflict grew to alter into increasingly greater unpopular, people who fought have been additionally derided and considered as a results of fact the villians. the U. S. executive loss of status on the autumn of Saigon, made them blind and deaf to the Vietnam Vet. as a results of fact they don't choose to settle for duty for failure interior the conflict thereby additionally for the veterans. The Vietnam Memorial at Arlington will tell the story not interior the lives lost yet look on the backside and niches there are products and mementos that provide the deeper thoughts of the Vietnam Vet. thank you for thinking of them.

  • 8 years ago

    Don;'t worry about it. I get thumbs down all the time for things that are absolutely true. If answers to you get nasty simply report them. Report them often enough and the nasties will have their accounts cancelled.

    My husband is a Pharmacist and even he gets thumbs down when he answers medical questions.

    It just shows the ignorance of some on here. Don't let it get to you. Whether or not you are a vet really doesn't matter if the information you give is correct.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.