Question for Nightwish fans?

When a band replaces one of their members, comparisons can't be avoided. That's normal. But continuously crying and b*tching about it even after 8 years since the band made the change, now that's a different story. So I sort of agree with you.

I agree. I never understood the Tarja/Anette/Floor debate. I really enjoy listening to any of them, although I have to admit that I think Anette has put in some sub-par live performances where she can't physically seem to hit the higher notes powerfully (still loved her in Nightwish, though). Really, Tuomas (and Emppu and Marko) make songs so epic that it hardly should matter who sings it as long as it's in key. Besides, the best vocalist is clearly Marko, anyway. =3

I find myself wondering the same thing. I dread going on You Tube to enjoy videos and music because people are constantly tearing each other apart because of different song choices. If they don't like the music, why can't they just leave and watch something enjoyable to them? Aye aye aye..

Because SOME of us actually loved Tarja, okay!? You can't just fall out of love with a woman like that...