Brady's 07 season vs Manning's season this year?

The best ever is still Marino, he threw 48 before it was flag football which is crazy good.

@Broncos, Celtic.... Seriously dude? The Patriots had to rally back several times that year, because their defense didn't do well in those games. Examples: vs colts, vs ravens, vs eagles vs giants.

I'll go with Brady. That offense destroyed the bad teams they played, and they destroyed two 13-3 teams as well, Manning's offense this year didn't destroy any of the good teams they played, and they couldn't do sheeeet at home vs the inconsistent Chargers, they only put up 7 points in the 2nd half against a banged up Pats secondary. 07 Brady would've shredded this year's Chargers D at home, and would've torn apart this year's Pats secondary as well

This is not tennis or boxing where players win individually. The Patriots won those games and lost the Super Bowl, not Brady.

The season is not over yet, we will know when it's over.

I will say that Tom Brady's 2007 season was better. However, I believe that Drew Brees' 2011 season was better than both.

I'd say the 07 Patriots. That season up until the Super Bowl was far more impressive.

Brady won every game because defense Manning did better than Brady this year than 07 Brady don't be mad but if your saying which team was better than NE

Extra-Brady did great but not better than Manning and Defense is better than Broncos if Broncos didn't gave up 30 points again NE and Colts and didn't give up those big runs against SD we would've been undefeated

It's a mute point. With the rules today created to favor passing offenses, these records will continue to fall every couple of seasons. Both are great QB's, but neither would have this success in the 1980's and 90's.

Bellicheat made a HUGE mistake. He could have benched Brady in favor of Tebow, a much better athlete, but no...

From the standpoint that Peyton did it on two different teams with completely different players, coaches, and 4 neck procedures....I'll say Peyton. His 04 season was the best of the three.

Peyton's offense this season has surpassed Brady's 07 season in every facet.