Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Is my dad right in this situation?
So here's the back story: At the end of last summer, my mother was diagnosed with terminal cancer and right now she is in her final days. A lot of people have been giving us meals these past few months considering the circumstances. Tomorrow is my birthday and this lady wanted to make me a birthday dinner. We told her it was fine and that we had everything taken care of, but she didn't listen. She went out of her way and bought salmon, rolls, vegetables, even a big birthday cake. My family has already made a cake for me so now we have two cakes. One of my friends wanted to do something nice for me by taking me ice skating. The ice skating rink is in an area filled with homeless people begging for money. I thought it would be nice if we could maybe bring the cake the lady brought for me, and pass out slices to the homeless people sort of like an act of kindness. Everybody has been so nice to us these past few months, I thought I would pass on the kindness to people in need. When I told my father this, he got really mad and said it was disrespectful to give away a cake that some lady went out of her way to buy for us. He said I shouldn't give it to random people Ii don't know or care about, and if Ii really wanted to give it away, I should give it to this lady that has been here for us the entire time. This lady is upper middle class, by the way and doesn't really need a cake. No matter how many times I explained my reasons for giving it to the homeless, he wouldn't let me do it and he just got angrier. Is he wrong in this situation, or was my plan actually disrespectful?
2 Answers
- abracaLv 67 years ago
Your plan was not disrespectful. But for now just go along with your dad, the whole family is on edge now and it is a time just to be together and be OK with one another. You have your whole life to do for the homeless if you want. Right now just go along with things. It will make your life easier in the moment. Sorry you are losing your mom.
- Anonymous7 years ago
well the cake was made for you... therefore you should be allowed to with it what you want... and people do this all the time. And the woman made the cake even though you said you didn't need/want it. I think what you did is fine