Hits with Creepy Themes?

My wife and I were listening to hits of 1980 last night and watched/listened to Benny Mardones' hit, "Into the Night." I know this song from middle school and hadn't heard it in a long time, but it's one helluva creepy song. Mr. Middle-Ager sings of his love affair with a 16-year old and how others don't understand it. I can't imagine that song being a hit today.

Any songs you know that were moderate (or bigger) hits that now seem creepy?