I'm torn between two guys! HELP!?

Hi! I'm currently a junior in high school and I need some help. There's these two guys that I've been talking to. One I have been talking to since my sophomore year. The other one I talked to in 7th grade and then we stopped talking, but we have recently started to talk again. They're both really sweet and they're such gentlemen. But that's about as far as the similarities go. The one that I have been talking to since sophomore year(let's call him Anonymous #1) plays football and he wrestles. He does have a bit of an ego, but he's one of those guys where he's a tough guy on the outside, but on the inside he's a softy. However, he has never talked to me in school except once. But, he was in my calculus class and he noticed a lot of things about me. The other one, the one I talked to in 7th grade(let's call him Anonymous #2), plays no sports whatsoever. He doesn't have much of an ego, but he's a guy that actually likes to talk about his feelings(with someone he trusts). He has talked to me in school, before, but barely. He doesn't notice much about who I am and I feel like even though we know each other, we have to get to know each other again because we've changed so much since 7th grade.

Both guys I really like and they treat me really well. I'm torn between them. I need your help. Who should I pick? I really don't like breaking hearts, but this is putting a lot of stress on me. Please help!