Are these german shepherd puppies good?

Are the parents OFA tested at the very LEAST? Do the parents have any working or show titles? If not, they're NOT good quality. "purebred" and "in general not sick" shouldn't even cross your mind. What you do need to focus on is the breeder along with the sire and dam... not the puppies.

Does the breeder offer lifetime support? Lifetime health guarantee? Lifetime return policy? OFA scores? Show or working titles? Good breeders have all of this because they produce GOOD dogs instead of throwaway dogs.

Also, what are you looking for? There are 4 types of GSDs believe it or not. 1. Working lines 2. American show lines 3. European show lines and 4. Poor quality, no specific standard, "family pet" Backyard Bred dogs. The 4th type is the type you want to completely avoid.

About the picture... I find most Backyard Breeders hold as many puppies as they can and crop the person's face out of the picture. Does that seem very professional to you? If you found this on Kijiji, Craigslist, eBay, Hoobly or any other classifieds RUN.

The photo address given (on flicker) does not work for me. NO ONE can tell the quality or worth of a puppy, at 4 weeks of age (aka 28 days). The first poster answered your question 100% correctly, in my opinion.

Y!A refuses to save my answer to either version of this question. You'll have to either wait for Y!A to fix whatever bug is interfering (possibly the length of my answer - but Y!A/neo/ is giving NO information as to a reason), or join my discussion group:

https://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/GSD_Friendly/i...

and ask your question there with ALL the details from both versions of this question. Some people there KNOW about GSDs. Plus you can include actual photos in your posts.

King Les The Lofty - first pup in 1950; GSD breeder & trainer as of 1968