Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
What would be sufficient evidence?
If you've been around here long enough, you'll know that its not uncommon here to have someone ask for a vet to answer their question.
The standard set of replies is "there are no vets here... go and find one in the real world" or some such thing.
Now this presents me with a difficulty. You see... I actually am a vet. I come on here because I find it quite interesting to see what questions people will ask, and what miscommunications happen in clinic. What people don't want to call their vet about, etc.
I think it makes me a better vet. I'm better able to anticipate where the problems might come in, and what "Dr. Google" might tell them.
I'm generally pretty selective in the questions I answer, giving no more advice than what I'd give to anyone calling me up on the phone at the clinic.
Now... sometimes I mention I'm a vet, sometimes I don't. (really depends on the question and my mood at the moment). I find in general I get a lot of negative backlash on things where do mention it. This isn't the only forum I hang around. This is however the only group I see such negativity when I say "I'm a vet".
So here is the thing --- lets take for a given that there is the occasional vet around here (not many mind you, but we do exist --- note I'm not asking you to believe the I'm a vet, just that there might be a few vets around here), what evidence would be enough to convince you?
9 Answers
- Land-sharkLv 77 years agoFavorite Answer
It just is not possible to present foolproof credentials on an online forum, especially when anything digitally produced can be faked with relative ease. Even if you put a phone number to your office it could be a scam like the bank account identity theives too often get away with.
Try to bear in mind that a sizeable number of people here are very young and will vote 'best answer' for the one they feel to be the most 'cool' or conformative to the mores of their peer group. Likewise they will TD anything they feel is 'uncool like telling them to grow up. Then there will be trolls and other fantasists; it's just part of internet forum life.
Good answers are always appreciated by others even if the asker doesn't get it.
One problem though, is that with dire symptoms being described, the only sensible answer is to to advise them to go immediately to an emergency vet because the problem could be x, y or z.
- ?Lv 77 years ago
Aw Dale, I know how you feel. I research my answers and never answer with anything I don't know to be the truth and very accurate. But much to my dismay, the asker usually chooses some half-baked answer that doesn't even make sense. I think there are a lot of trolls here that just come to make fun of people and harass them. If you told me you were a vet, I'd believe you. Why would you lie? Besides, I'm intelligent enough to know the difference between a good answer and a bunch of bull. We appreciate you and are fortunate to benefit from your knowledge. Just add that you're a vet, many of us will believe you.
- Anonymous7 years ago
"what evidence would be enough to convince you?"
Why do you feel the need to convince anyone?
As Lizzie said, we've had many people claim to be vets. With most of them, if you check their questions, you find out they are teenagers. People can say anything online. And as you must realize, the trouble with someone's claiming to be a vet when they AREN'T could mean that the Asker of that particular question thinks he can believe that answer--when in fact that answer could be dead wrong and possibly cost the life of the dog.
Further, I've known a few vets who have given terrible advice (to me and to people I trust to tell me the truth). So even if you are a vet, nobody's perfect. None of us on this forum are perfect but we try to give the best advice we can.
I see you get upset when you've gotten TD's: https://ca.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20...
ALL of us get TD's. Even on the occasions when our answers are correct with no wiggle-room to argue. An example: a few months ago a poster who popped up on several questions about rabies claiming humans couldn't contract that virus. Of course he was dead wrong. But when I refuted his claim I got TD's, sometimes more than one, even when I posted links from CDC and other reliable sources proving my point. Go figure. Trolls and other "fans".
In conclusion: post here when and if you feel like it, but for your own sake lose the thin skin. If people TD you or don't believe you're a vet, so what? Don't let it bother you.
- CDogLv 77 years ago
I've seen your answers and I believe you are a vet. I also see kids on here claiming to be vets and vet techs. But you, I believe, are a vet. Your answers are what have convinced me. I also believe it is plausible that a vet would visit this site at times.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- JenVTLv 77 years ago
Don't you worry that giving advice without an examination would open you up to a mal-practice suit? That would be my concern if you indeed are a vet and are dispensing advice in that capacity.
- 4Her4LifeLv 77 years ago
In most locations there is a huge legal difference between offering free advice without examining the animal as a layman and as a board-certified veterinarian. I would cease and desist before you lose your license. That is my major concern with those who say they are "vets" - either they are ignorant of standard practice (in that case, what else do they not know?) or they are lying, 99% of the time.
Give a solid answer if you feel compelled to do so - but DO NOT claim your professional certifications unless you want to lose your license.
- LizzieLv 77 years ago
We have had so very many wannabe vets in the past that it is hard to believe anyone who claims to be one.