Would this be a fair trade?

Question

I'm offering:
WR: Brandon Marshall
RB: Andre Williams

I'm asking:
RB: LeSean McCoy

I really need a RB2 since besides Ellington I have guys like Williams, Sankey, Simms, and Taliaferro since AP has been suspended all year and Stacy at this point is useless. Also, the person I'm trading has guys like Foster, Ingram, Hillman, while having guys like Torrey Smith and Boldin as WR's. So he needs WR while I need RB since I already have Antonio Brown, Emmanuel Sanders, Kelvin Benjamin, Mike Wallace, and Allen Robinson who are all very solid.

So is what I'm offering a fair deal? I get back a Tier 1 RB who could potentially bounce back for a Tier 1 WR that could also potentially bounce back and a RB who could take McCoy's role for the time being...

conley39 · Answer

Given McCoy's underperformance this year with only one great game, it's not a terrible offer. Marshall has underperformed and Williams will be going back to a backup role when Jennings is back in the lineup. I would not accept the deal if I owned McCoy and would counter for a little better RB in place of Williams if you have one.

Messykatt · Answer

I think it's a very good trade for you, and a "fair" offer to him..  McCoy's improvement has been at a snail's pace, and there's always risk that his OL could regress, but he's slowly becoming a bigger part of that offense.  There's no telling when or if the Bears offense gets it together.

zackattack728 · Answer

Personally if I was him I would not accept it and instead try to send foster or hillman. If you can get McCoy from those two players that's a great deal for you, just depends how he wants his team to go forward.

Trending News

Would this be a fair trade?

3 Answers