Boxing: Who did better against Floyd, Maidana in the first fight or Cotto?

Maidana

Maidana was awesome against Floyd.

Maidana because you could make a case he nearly won. Cotto at best won 3 rounds and that's it.

Chino had the Philly shell defense like the back of his hand. That's why he kayoed Broner and beat him silly. He almost beat Floyd in their first fight. And "almost" was "actually" to many. I had the fight draw, although the first time i'd seen it, i had Floyd winning via razor thin margin. Even FLoyd wasnt convinced so he let for a rematch. Cotto on the other hand made a cauliflower of FLoyd's ears. But it was a Floyd win nonetheless. It was clear as broad day light, FLoyd won that fight

Cotto hiso mejor trabajo los golpes de Maidana no tenia direccion los golpes en la espada y la nuca no valen . El mis Mayweather dijo que Cotto a sido el rival que mas dificil en su carerra dijo que nunca habia sentido un pegada como de Cotto

Maidana

I haven't seen the Cotto fight since I watched it on fight night but if I remember rightly he won more than 3 rounds so Cotto.

Chino. And I don't like to watch another Floyd v Cotto though Miguel managed to hurt him, too.

I believed it's Cotto otherwise Floyd already gave him the rematch.

Cotto. He fought very smart and very well while Maidana just fought dirty.