I'll ask again, What deserving MLB players belong in the HOF? McGriff,Trammell,Mattingly,Guidry,Saberhagen etc.?

I would likely vote for all of the following:

Catchers - Mike Piazza

First Basemen - Jeff Bagwell, Keith Hernandez, Mark McGwire

Second Basemen - Bobby Grich, Willie Randolph, Lou Whitaker

Third Basemen - Sal Bando, Buddy Bell, Ken Boyer, Graig Nettles

Shortstops - Bill Dahlen, Jack Glasscock, Alan Trammell

Outfielders - Barry Bonds, George Gore, Paul Hines, Kenny Lofton, Lip Pike, Tim Raines, Reggie Smith, Larry Walker

Pitchers - Kevin Brown, Roger Clemens, Jim McCormick, Mike Mussina, Curt Schilling, Luis Tiant

Designated Hitters - Edgar Martinez

Fred McGriff and Don Mattingly

Of the carryovers

- Mike Piazza

- Jeff Bagwell (maybe)

- Tim Raines (maybe)

- Edgar Martinez (I doubt he will ever make it)

Eligible in 2016

- Ken Griffey Jr.

- Trevor Hoffman

Eligible in 2017

- Vladimir Guerrero

- Manny Ramirez

- Ivan Rodriguez

Eligible in 2018

- Andruw Jones

- Chipper Jones

- Jim Thome

- Omar Vizquel

Eligible in 2019

- Roy Halladay

- Andy Pettitte

- Mariano Rivera

Eligible in 2020:

- Derek Jeter

I'm going add Steve Gsrvey(LA Dodgers,SD Padres first baseman.

Played in 5 WS,1974 NL MVP,Played in 1207 straight games.

Pete Rose

Mike Piazza

Willie McCovey

I'd probably vote for the Crime Dog out of the ones you mentioned. Maybe Donnie Baseball.

Bagwell, Piazza and McGriff. (McGriff should of played a few more weeks and he would of gotten the homer mark)

Donnie Baseball and Pete Rose! The other player$ are roider$!

Go Yanks!

I'm still waiting for Tony Olivia & Jim Katt to get in.

Of the ones you named, only McGriff merits the plaque.