Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

? asked in SportsOutdoor RecreationHunting · 6 years ago

Ruger Redhawk CC?

Is a ruger Redhawk .44 magnum a good gun for concealed carry? Ive read a lot about over penetration and difficulty with follow up shots but none of these seem to match the gun it has I believe a 2.75 inch barrel and is very easily concealable. My next point is the follow up shot my Redhawk does NOT have "wrist breaking hit u in the face recoil" it's actually pretty mild at least to me and I can hit a row of cans pretty quick even at 15 yards. And the over penetration I can see this if using a bear round or something but when paired with a .44 special which is similar to a .45 acp it seems to add up to a fine cc weapon but ivr also heard if u have to shoot someone the court wil trash u for using such a powerful gun i dont see why it matters if u are protecting your life so I don't know

3 Answers

Relevance
  • 6 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    No it's not a good gun for conceal carry. You're focusing on the wrong things. It would be amazingly rare if you ever have to pull the trigger of your conceal carry gun in self defense yet that's what people new to conceal carry seem to focus on. People who ACTUALLY carry all day every day focus on things like how heavy the gun is, how easy it is to conceal and how much it prints. In that way the Redhawk just isn't a good conceal gun. It's heavy and big. It weighs between 2 and 3 times as much as the purpose built Ruger LCR which is much smaller, lighter and easier to conceal.

    Don't fall into the trap of thinking that your bullet needs to drop someone and you must have the mythological "stopping power." That's Internet BS. One thing all the Internet tough guys never think about is "do I really want to kill someone?" You can't undo it. You can't take the shot back. You can't "un-see" their chest exploding.

    My advice is to get something that's purposely built for every day conceal carry. Something like the LCR if you're into revolvers. No one wants to have a searing hot .38 diameter hole in their body. You don't have to worry about stopping power. You're not in the military where your opponent has two options: fight on or die. In self defense your opponent has two options: run or stay and get shot. Sorry, but you and all your crap aren't worth anyone sticking around to get shot at. They'll run away and move on to an easier target.

  • 6 years ago

    44 oz (not including ammo) - that is 2.75 lbs of steel or about the weight of 5.5 rolls of quarters and is also the weight of the 2.75" .44 mag Redhawk. So while its smallish barrel makes it feasible size for the concealed carry, it still is a lot of mass to hang on your belt. On the other hand a .357 mag revolver will be an inch shorter in overall length and be only 60% of the weight and be more than capable for concealed carry.

    And yes, if you do choose a .44 mag, you should plan on buy a lot of .44 special, which is actually not super common or super cheap. You will get a lot more options with a .357 magnum with more resonable ammo costs and the option to shoot .38 special.

    I recommend you sign up for a defensive handgun course, because I don't think you understand the follow up shot issue. It is not about not being able to handle recoil, it is about getting back on target and getting the next shot off as quickly as possible. No matter how fast you can make follow up shots with a .44 mag (and I don't think you are as fast as you think you are in the real world), you can always be significantly faster with a lower recoil handgun.

  • Anonymous
    6 years ago

    Its middling. If that's all you've got then it will have to do. But for myself I'd sure want something a lot more powerful.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.