Fantasy Football?

This can't be answered because you're leaving out one of the biggest components of all: luck. Also, for the parts that don't involve luck, you didn't give the kind of info that helps determine who's better. It doesn't matter about who spends more time, or what their record is.

It's other things. For example, I won a league this year that was on its 16th season. All of us are savvy and good players. Yet I have never spent less time on a league in my life. I kept the right players, I drafted well, everyone stayed healthy, and I lucked into a couple things like Davonta Freeman.

I probably spent a total of 15 minutes total doing bye week replacements or whatever. I've also been in leagues where I have to spend double that every week just to stay competitive. In a 12 team league last season, I picked last and I grabbed Dez Bryant, DeMarco Murray and then in next rounds Keenan Allen and Dion Lewis. My QBs were Romo and Manning.

So yeah, I got beaten by some idiot who had 3 kickers and 3 TE's on his roster. It wasn't because he's a better player, lol.

Not remotely enough information. Obviously you aren't talking about the same league if Jim won 11 times and Mark 9, this is all in the last 15 years.

JIm could be in 17 leagues and Mark 5.

No one cares about H2H matchups. That's just a single week.

To me it's all about the championships/trophys..

Jim is better.

I can't remember h2h match ups & regular season wins much from the past 16 years,but I can always look in my trophy case to see my trophys.