Who is better?

I asked this question a few days ago, with very little response. So, I am trying again, so that I can get a clearer answer.

Hi, There are 2 Fantasy Football players. Tom and Steve. Tom has been playing since 2003. Steve has been playing since 2005. Their overall head to head record in regular season is Tom 24 and Steve 21. Their overall head to head record in the playoffs is tied at 3 a piece. Tom has 12 trophies ( 4 first place, 5 second, and 3 third). Steve has 12 trophies ( 4 first place, 6 second, and 2 third). Overall, who do you think is the better Fantasy Football player? I wanted to add that Steve started out the head to head winning most of the head to head matchups, while Tom won the most in the middle, but Steve has most recently won 5 in a row.