Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Question about German pronoun?
I'm (re-) learning German from Duolingo, after some 30 years off since high school.
Today the sentence came up "Es ist ein Apfel." My question is why you would use 'Es' instead of 'Er'. After all, 'Apfel' is masculine -- der Apfel.
I'm sure there's a good reason; I'd like to know what that is. Thanks!
5 Answers
- don_sv_azLv 73 years agoFavorite Answer
Because the subject "it" is unknown gender until you get to object apple.
- ?Lv 73 years ago
learn languages with people who speak their mothertongue and you can teach your language in exchange (free of charge but i prefered the 20$ a year to email user directly)
www.mylanguageexchange.com
- Anonymous3 years ago
The German personal pronoun "es" is the English equivalent of "it" and has similar functions. Therefore, it can be used in a sentence such as your example.
- ?Lv 73 years ago
Guessing (it's been a long time since I learned German...)
For the same reason you would use neuter "it" in English.
That is: because the word "it" itself is neuter
and so when you mean some as-yet unidentified or ungendered object, you use the neuter.
Similarly in English:
- It's a boy (rather than "He's a boy")
- It's a guy, not a girl
etc.
It projects the idea of a gender becoming recognized
So - for example - of a thing unrecognized becoming recognized.
It is at first unrecognized (and thus a neuter "thing")
and then (by the end of the sentence) is identified, including gender.
- MarkLv 73 years ago
Well, it is colloquial and VERY common... "Es ist ein Maedchen" is correct, but no one would say "'it' is a girl", would they?