Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

?
Lv 6

Astrology followers. What do you make of this article from UAE that shows planetary influence on Earth and perhaps earthly events?

Update 2:

Watch the skeptics spit up their Lucky Charms cereal and rant without reading it

Update 3:

I never said it would validate astrology or resulting personality effects. Only one person seemed to notice that. I just asked for feedback, and what I got was a lot of defensive blather.

Update 4:

What about the last sentence: ""Yet the emerging evidence for planets influencing the Sun and thereby global events suggests that the real problem with astrology is that its claims were simply too modest?"

5 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    2 years ago

    I see "Anonymous'" prediction came true. The skeptics aren't responding to the article and its implications but rather to what THEY think is astrology. In other words theirs is a straw man argument.

    >>Nothing about a planet controlling or influencing the daily activities of a person<<

    No one said it did. Straw man argument.. Read it again and try to understand it.

    >>"While we are no more likely to meet an exciting new friend if Mars is in alignment with Jupiter, there is no doubt that these celestial bodies affect our planet as a whole."<<

    So the celestial bodies affect the whole planet but not humans at all? Really? Really? Climate change alarmists must be relieved. Hint: anything that affects the whole earth affects humans and human activity. The mini ice age proves that, so do warming periods.

    The idea that astrology is only "You will meet a new love interest on Thursday," is one promoted by people who don't know any astrology.

    What we have is a bunch of skeptics desperately looking to shoot holes in a valid scientific study that they don't understand, but are in a panic over. In order to fully grasp the significance one needs to know astrology, a lo more than than the author, and then grasp the implications of the study that is the topic of the article. Then you heads won't explode.

  • Adam D
    Lv 7
    2 years ago

    I fail to see what the information in this article has to do with astrology. It is obvious that the bodies in our solar system are interconnected, and the measurable actions of the largest bodies are the farthest reaching.

  • 2 years ago

    It's an interesting article. It says nothing at all that would validate "astrology." Modern science shows that the other planets can have physical effects on the earth and its climate. Swell, that's believable.

    In no way does that indicate that a person's day, week, or personality are affected by the particular position of the planets at the time of the person's birth, nor that medieval fortune-tellers could have figured out how to predict any such connection.

  • Anonymous
    2 years ago

    You didn't read it, did you.

    It says the other planets may have influenced the EARTH's climate and therefore HUMAN history.

    Nothing about a planet controlling or influencing the daily activities of a person.

    "While we are no more likely to meet an exciting new friend if Mars is in alignment with Jupiter, there is no doubt that these celestial bodies affect our planet as a whole."

  • Anonymous
    2 years ago

    It doesn't say anything about the effects on personality (and that's good), but it does say things about links with climate, which in turn affects events. It also proposes a mechanism that skeptics desperately hang on to in order to rationalize their a priori reasoning.

    Watch for heads to explode when the read this last sentence: "Yet the emerging evidence for planets influencing the Sun and thereby global events suggests that the real problem with astrology is that its claims were simply too modest."

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.