Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

? asked in Entertainment & MusicMovies · 8 months ago

If Mulan's family speaks English as their first language in the live action movie, why do they have accents that suggest otherwise?

Unless chinese is their first language and all of china decided to speak English instead, it is an example of using english when we all know they wouldn't be way back before countries were friendly with each other and shared stuff about their languages and cultures.

It's like in doctor who, where the tardis translates everything for you with special science, but everyone will have accents relating to Earth. Accents that native English speaking would have (mainly accents originating in the UK).

It's not like they make up an accent an alien would have if they learned English. Secondly, when they go to countries that don't have many English speakers, their accents don't change at all! 

In Mulan, many characters have Chinese accents. But why not just have them speak Chinese or have an accent that native English speakers have? It just doesn't make sense to me.

Same with Uncle Iroh from Avatar: the last airbender. Yes, he is my favorite character from the show forever and always, but his father didn't speak another language, his brother didn't, and he doesn't seem to... So, why does he speak like it is his second language? 

So many questions...

2 Answers

Relevance
  • 8 months ago

    Movies are for entertainment of an audience. The audience for Mulan and the last airbender was North America, where English is the main spoken language.

    As for the accent(s)... it's to imply that they are not speaking english, but their own language, whatever it is. Like Mel Gibson in Braveheart -- william wallace with an aussie accent would look ridiculous; Sean Connery (if he were younger) would have been more realistic, but David Tenant was too scrawny to carry off the role.

    Stop nit-picking, and suspend disbelief -- you'll enjoy the movies more

  • Steel
    Lv 7
    8 months ago

    This film and the shows you mention don't exist in a vacuum, and they have an intended target audience for whom it would be of great benefit to be able to understand the dialog.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.