Harry Potter vs Lord of the rings vs Chronicles of Narnia?

Favorite Answer

So far no one has compared the "heros vs heros, villians vs villans" part of the question...

Hero's VS Hero's
Harry Potter VS Frodo Baggins VS The 5 Siblings

I give Frodo from The Lord of the Rings the victory here. The kids from Narnia had each other and their were 5 of them (once Edmund came around) and they had the help of Santa, Aslan, and an entire army at their disposal. Harry Potter takes a close second, he is brave and does whats right, but he is a wizard and has lots of help through his friends and the friends of his parents who look out for him. Frodo has the Fellowship, but he knew the trip to Mordor would probably mean his death, he knew the Ring would cause the other members to turn on him, he knew the Ring would attract evil, but he still went on.

Villians VS Villans
Lord Voldemort VS Sauron VS The Witch

I have to give the prize to Lord Voldemort, with Sauron a close second. The Witch was evil, but not evil enough. She generally stones her victems rather than killing them, and if she had been truly evil, she would have killed Edmund at the start thus preventing the phrophecy. Sauron was much worse, he intended to conquer the world as the Witch had done, but the world would have become a world of orcs, no mercy to the races of Men, Elves or Dwarves. But, I give the prize to Voldemort because he has no monsters fighting for him, just a few followers, and he did not hesitate to have Wormtounge kill the other boy (I forget his name) that tied with Harry reaching the Tri-Wizard Cup. He was also not going to make any mistakes about killing Harry Potter, if you listen when he forces Harry to dual he uses the Killing Curse right away. If the wands had not locked and the spirits shown up to help he would have killed Harry then and there....Show more

I say Lord of the Rings by a long shot because this question is in the movies section. If we were talking about books Harry Potter might win but I haven't read the Lord of the Rings books. The Harry Potter movies are great but aren't the masterpieces that the books are. The Lord of the Rings movies on the other hand are masterpieces....Show more

I couldn't pick between Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings, but both series definitely beat the Chronicles of Narnia....Show more

Harry Potter...Show more

Harry Potter...Show more