Better QB Ben Roethlisberger or Michael Vick?
I need help settling an office debate. Forget about all off field trouble. If you were the owner of a team who would you rather have QB your team? Who is the Better QB????
I need help settling an office debate. Forget about all off field trouble. If you were the owner of a team who would you rather have QB your team? Who is the Better QB????
John
Favorite Answer
There's no question about it...Big Ben is the better QB by a long shot.
Scout729
It isn't even a comparison. Its great Vick can run but he a quarterback. He needs an arm and he doesn't have one. He was the most overpaid and overrated player in the NFL. Roethlisberger is a great QB and already has a ring. Ben has learned what to do to make him even more of a threat. Vick never got any better - the only thing Vick could do was run
Roethlisberger all the way
Anonymous
Ben Roethlisberger
triplezero19
Roethlisberger. no question. Vick was never a great passer. Ben can not only throw, he can also run with it. Though he doesn't have Vick- like speed. The only thing that bothers me about Roethlisbeger is that he seems to be at his worst when he has to throw the ball over 30 times a game. When he only has to throw 20 passes a game he's great.
TL
I'd take Big Ben in a heartbeat over Vick for an NFL, both had great potential but only one ever lived up to it. Big Ben will solidify Pitt's QB position for the next decade, Vick will always have been a "wait till next year" player.
In college, I'd take Vick, where playing against less skilled defensive players his athletic ability would allow him to make more impressive plays.