What to do about in-laws that won't follow my rules?

Long story short, my in-laws are a nightmare. We live a block away and I have a two year old daughter, so we are between the two houses constantly. The problem is them not following our rules in reguard to what we want our daughter eating. I never had weight issues as a child, so I am mostly just concerned about her developing healthy eating habits for life. My husband, on the other hand, grew up in a house where everyone over-eats and basically eats junk all the time. He was very obese as a child and has had to work extremley hard to get fit and stay fit, so he is also concerned about our daughter learning the habits that he learned at a young age and having to go through everything he did as the "fat kid" at school, then having to feel deprived of something when she has to change her eating habits in the future. We have been very direct in conveying our rules and they blatently disregard anything they think is "silly". Don't get me wrong, we're not food Natzi's or anything..

2008-07-05T19:49:27Z

We just have basic rules like only one snack in between meals, we eat meals at the table, one treat after dinner, milk or water, no juice, things like that. But every time I turn around someone is sneaking her snacks behind our back. I have been good natured up until this point but I just walked in on his grandmother feeding her a jumbo sized piece of key lime pie ten minutes before her bed-time. I about blew my lid. I don't know what to do short of just not taking her there anymore. I just picked her up and left because I didn't want to say something that I would regret later, but I'm not sure how I could be more clear. I'm ready to tell them that I am going to start paying a babysitter to watch my daughter when I am not home (usually she stays with them) just to make sure things are done the way I want. It's been causing her to have terrible tantrums at home now because she doesn't get the things she gets there. I'm at wits end...any ideas or help is appreciated, thanks!

2008-07-06T10:02:11Z

Wow...thanks to everyone who answered. I'm working my way through reading all the answers now, but I just wanted to comment on a few...

First of all, this is not an occasional treat I am talking about. This has been going on since my daughter was three weeks old and they tried to sneak rice cereal in her bottle. At three months old they started with the juice and the solid food. I asked them repeatedly not to per doc's orders (really) but continued to find baby juice in the garbage and chunks in her formula. It only got worse when she began to eat real food. Now she expects a cookie every time she walks through the kitchen.

I don't give my daughter juice because her pediatrician specifically recommends against it. It is all sugar and empty calories. She eats plenty of fruit for vitamins and also takes a toddler multivitamin everyday.

Finaly, I do not "take advantage" of their free babysitting. I have a job that allows me to bring my daughter with me, so I rarely ask for...

2008-07-06T10:18:32Z

them to watch her, it is very much the opposite. Her grandmother calls me nearly every morning to ask if I can bring her by. I can do just about anything I need to with my daughter so dropping her off is not a necessity, I do it as a favor to them because I know they enjoy her company. Even when I sit in the house with them grandma will sneak my daughter things, literally while my back is turned so I feel like I have to follow her from room to room. Because we live so close, she can look out the window and see if my car is home so when I don't answer the phone she just walks over. Grrr....

Once again, I am not a food nazi. I am all about letting kids be kids, but I want to also instill healthy habits in her now so that when she does have to make choices for herself hopefully they will be healthy ones. Family medical history includes diabetes, heart disease, obesity, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, etc. and that's just one generation.

Master M2008-07-05T20:04:44Z

Favorite Answer

****EDIT*****
YOUR HUSBAND WILL HAVE TO ask them, "We did tell you, didn't we, that we didn't want that being done?" (That narrows it down to a yes/no question that makes explanation an inappropriate answer) - and if they try to "explain" he can re-ask the question "BUT, Did we tell you we don't want that being done?" And regardless of their explanation, he may acknowledge their reasoning, but return to the fact that she is YOUR daughter, and you have specifically asked certain rules to be followed, by not following rules themselves they are teaching your child to be a truant to her parents, that her parents rules are unimportant, and that this is about a LOT more than just snacks, but is setting YOUR daughter up to be disobedient, dishonest and untrustworthy and you don't want that kind of example set for her, nor do you want people who do those kinds of things making YOU out to be something other than a loving parent just because you have rules, and that they are losing their babysitting PRIVELEDGES until they demonstrate that THEY can be trusted to follow rules and be responsible.

He needs to say it with love, say a prayer, and be tactful, and hopefully this will make things clear. Sometimes, there's no substitute for being honest.

You may have to not allow her to be watched for a while by them, and ultimately, I would consider moving away from the in-laws to get a bit of freedom if finances and opportunity present themselves.

?2014-10-29T17:10:24Z

They don't realise today it's a tough battle with all the crud on supermarket shelves, which is backed up by more advertising that you can possibly block out.

Maybe if you're going over there just to visit for a little bit, take some healthier snacks of your own to share with everyone. If they're looking after her for you for periods of time I'm guessing they won't be told. I know my mother will listen attentively to my concerns and then throw them all out the window the minute my back is turned. I gave her a list of food additives and their effects (whether good or bad) and she does check it - while an improvement it hasn't fully fixed the situation. Just keep reinforcing your rules at home and try your best with the inlaws. You can only do what you can do and lead by example for your child.

?2015-01-11T05:53:14Z

Maybe if you're going over there just to visit for a little bit, take some healthier snacks of your own to share with everyone. If they're looking after her for you for periods of time I'm guessing they won't be told. I know my mother will listen attentively to my concerns and then throw them all out the window the minute my back is turned. I gave her a list of food additives and their effects (whether good or bad) and she does check it - while an improvement it hasn't fully fixed the situation. Just keep reinforcing your rules at home and try your best with the inlaws. You can only do what you can do and lead by example for your child.

Power Flower2008-07-05T21:10:58Z

Eeeeeeeee - that must be so hard with the in-laws living so close!

I know grandparents think they are older and wiser ... and the reality is, they grew up during a time when if a treat wasn't made with just flour, eggs, milk and sugar - it probably didn't exist!

They don't realise today it's a tough battle with all the crud on supermarket shelves, which is backed up by more advertising that you can possibly block out.

Maybe if you're going over there just to visit for a little bit, take some healthier snacks of your own to share with everyone. If they're looking after her for you for periods of time I'm guessing they won't be told. I know my mother will listen attentively to my concerns and then throw them all out the window the minute my back is turned. I gave her a list of food additives and their effects (whether good or bad) and she does check it - while an improvement it hasn't fully fixed the situation. Just keep reinforcing your rules at home and try your best with the inlaws. You can only do what you can do and lead by example for your child.

good luck!

♥Ani♥2008-07-07T21:01:40Z

I'm less concerned about them giving her a cookie, what my real problem would be is that they are completely disregarding your rules, (regardless of rather it's about food or what) and complete lack of respect. I do agree with the no juice rule, I also feel your husband's pain, although my mom tried to instill good habits, a thryoid problem (both over and underactive) runs in our family, especially among the women, but TRY explaining that to school children.

I would put my foot down and say "look this is our daughter, we will raise her the way we want to, even if you think it's silly, I still expect you to respect our rules, if you can't, we will have to seriously limit the visits" if they don't stop, I would limit the visits to maybe 5 or 10 mintues, or insist they come over to your house (and not bring any treats or anything). They are basically spoiling her with food, which is bad for her attitude (being spoiled) and for her health. It may not affect her now, but it will later in life. Sorry you have to deal with this, good luck.

Show more answers (238)