"Fort Hood Massacre" - over 100 rounds fired from 2 hand guns - no one jumped this person while reloading?

Not questioning anyone's bravery. The soldiers were unarmed. But this shooter must have reloaded. One pistol was a revolver - relatively slow to reload. 300 soldiers right there. Would not one of them jump this person and wrestle him down while reloading? Was everyone ducking and hiding? Same as the Virgina Tech shooting. People did not attack the attacker. Wonder what I would do? I hope I would have charged during the lull in firing. I guess we never know what we might do.

2009-11-06T19:04:44Z

I realize I might freeze as well. I have not had guns pointed and fired at me. I have not been a trained fighting man.
CNN is reporting right now that over 100 rounds were fired. One gun was a .357 magnum. That's a five round revolver. The other was an FN semi-automatic 5.7 mm. Maybe that held 15 rounds. He must have reloaded at least five times. The police arrived in 3 minutes, but they didn't take this person down right away.

2009-11-06T19:21:05Z

"Damocles" makes good sense. A policeman who was 15 yards from the major while he was still shooting just now said on CNN that the shooter was very calm in appearance.
He may indeed have been threatening with the .357 while reloading the .57 semi-auto. Maybe with that size round - .57 - the magazine might hold 20. I am familiar with revolvers and semi-autos. I have not seen a FN .57 cal. "cop killer." This is apparently a high penetration round. Multiple people could have been rounded by the same bullet. But they say that over 100 shots were fired by this army psychiatrist major - based on shell casings.

2009-11-06T19:23:49Z

Correction - that's 5.7 mm not .57 cal. - a huge difference in bullet size. I should have edited better. I've never seen one these 5.7 mm semi-automatics. There must be a large explosive charge and high muzzle velocity.

2009-11-06T19:44:29Z

I guess I somewhat expect that at least a group of 300 trained young solders would automatically charge en masse to minimize casualties.

2009-11-06T23:00:25Z

"million$.." has an excellent analysis.
Hindsight is 20/20. The people who rebelled on the downed 9/11/01 airliner had time to realize it was take the risk or die anyway.

2009-11-06T23:14:16Z

Seems like if everyone hit the deck when the shooting started, assessed the situation in less than one minute, gauged the reloading interval, then communicated a concerted plan of attack to the nearest soldiers for a rush, some casualties may have been averted. Resolute action under fire. Isn't that part of army training? These were not civilians or college students. Maybe war is a push button affair these days and no one really learns wrestling or hand to hand combat skills. For one man to take out 51 highly trained fighting men and women just seems strange. These days, it seems we should expect crazed gunmen attacks anywhere - from high schools to colleges to high rise NY office buildings. Why should a combat army post not expect an attack? We might all think about what we would do in such an instance. Plan ahead.

2009-11-06T23:24:20Z

Good answer "icabod" - I suspect everyone may have been running around in disorder and confusion - pushing and shoving in panic - waiting for a civilian police person with a gun to save them. That would be a normal human reaction. I might do the same. I hope I would not, but no one ever knows until it happens. We should all anticipate this insanity. It happened in my home town when I was 15, and the gunman was driving around shooting people. We at home had rifles at the ready watching for him to come by. Of course being fore-warned and fore-armed is quite a different scenario from the Fort Hood episode.

million$gon2009-11-06T19:53:35Z

Favorite Answer

"Hindsight is 20 20"

After that incident of history, we have some facts, just the facts.

During that surprise attack, no one there knew how many ready-to-fire guns he had, what kind of guns he had, whether it was just one or maybe more attackers or snipers, etc... There was no strategy in place for such an incident, and there was too much uncertainty for effective tactics, and it all happened so fast. People were in shock and survival was the first priority, attacking the attacker would naturally be second priority.

Damocles2009-11-06T18:56:48Z

"Over 100 rounds fired"? Where did you read that?

One of the reasons that so many people were hurt was because people were packed in there so tightly, that a single round would go through multiple people. The pistol would be relatively quick to reload. They do make quick reload devices for revolvers. Essentially they hold all the rounds, all lined up to go into the revolver. Press one button and they release. So you slide them in, hit the button, and viola, you've just reloaded. Still, once the speculation dies down and the facts come out, I'll bet he reloaded the pistol, keeping people at bay with the revolver.

FEZ2009-11-06T18:43:30Z

The next time a crazed gunman starts shooting at you see if you can disarm him. Semi automatic weapons can be reloaded within seconds, and trust me he wasn't just standing there reloading a revolver. The gun two guns he was using both had 20 round mags. That means he only reloaded 3 mags.

icabod2009-11-06T19:54:45Z

Most of us like to believe that we'd be the hero and charge. However, the majority of people will first freeze (what is happening?) then try and get away. With the crowd (the news tonight estimated 300 were in the room) that creates lots of motion, mostly away from the gunfire. SGT Munley is a firearms instructor, SWAT team member had was armed. It was all that training plus having a weapon that allowed her to take the gunman down.

Tsunami2009-11-06T18:38:43Z

he was armed and it was one or two pistols and not 100 rounds of amo. man that is how things get started. a civilian cop shot him 4 times and he wounded her. but she is making it hes on ventilator. hopefully hes still in coma and never come out. when sometime like this happens everyone is in shock. i mean tehy totally were shocked at first. that is what happened. you wold be the same. it took only 3 minutes into it and she shot him. you have to be there to find out what you would do i guess.

Show more answers (3)