To bring back lost jobs and save our capitalist economy from collapse, do US politicians need to let COVID-19 kill people?

2020-05-14T11:23:00Z

That's what seems to be happening right now.  While public health officials like Dr. Fauci warn about the spike in coronavirus cases that will result from reopening the economy "too soon," Trump and many, many state governors are rushing to reopen fairly quickly -- to save jobs.

2020-05-14T11:25:38Z

Aren't we basically talkling about a tragic choice here -- a "Catch-22" situation in which either choice we make is going to have really terrible side-effects?  If we keep the economy shut down, or mostly shut down, to slow the virus's spread and save lives, we risk adding to his country's 14.7 percent unemployment.  We risk seeing thousands and thousands of small businesses collapse across the USA.

2020-05-14T11:27:36Z

But if we rush to reopen the economy and allow small businesses (and big businesses) to stay in operation and provide more people with jobs, we're likely to give the virus a chance to spike in numbers again -- which could mean we have to shut down the economy again later, under emergency conditions.

2020-05-14T11:30:17Z

A liberal Nobel-Prize-winning economist, Joseph Stiglitz, stated some months ago that US capitalism as it exists today "lacks an emergency brake."  It just can't shut down for urgent reasons of safety without producing economic chaos.  What can we do in the future to make this system more flexible and able to protect BOTH jobs and prosperity AND public health?

Anonymous2020-05-14T11:40:56Z

YES............

Rebound2020-05-14T11:33:15Z

That's like asking if you shouldn't eat food because digestion uses up a large amount of calories and energy. If you don't eat, you collapse. Just like you have to spend energy to have energy, an economy must spend money to make money. The economy doesn't take a timeout just because 1% of people are at risk of dying from this disease.

Update: Lol so capitalism is defunct because it lacks an emergency brake? Hate to break it to you pal, but there isn't a system in the world that has an emergency break. There is no such thing as stagnation. Stagnant economies build up in financial waste the same way a stagnant swamp builds up with fish poop and grime.

?2020-05-14T11:22:22Z

No, of course not. Moreover wouldn't losing a huge chunk of the US population to sickness/death also cripple the economy as well?

Anonymous2020-05-14T11:22:04Z

That’s capitalism in a nutshell. 

Anonymous2020-05-14T11:21:56Z

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fMrLLWY_QaY&feature=em-uploademail

Show more answers (3)