Should Katharine McPhee have won American Idol??

I also think that Katharine McPhee should have won American Idol. What bothers me more is the fact that Taylor had to make a commercial for the Ford Company right after his win. The commercial runs all the time, it is driving me crazy. The ad is very silly and annoying. A record artist should never tie themselves so closely to a big company ad, it takes away from your artistic Independence.

Oh no. i dont think she shouldnt have made it that far either, as a lot of people, -maybe all- were more talented than she is. Taylor deserved to win, he was the most original (apart from Chris, who from what I heard is a real asshole, and thought that he was already a star on the show, and was really nasty to the cast. Some even think that the producers might be the ones who actually booted him off). Elliot was really good too, and deserves to go far.

I don't think so. I liked Taylor. He's different. Katharine will probably become an actress or a model. She's very pretty, but I thought she sang like a lot of other singers.

She'll do well even if she didn't win. I preferred her over Taylor but I thought he deserved it too. I voted for Katherine after Chris was voted off!!

No, Chris should have won.

And I'm saying that in spite of the fact that he sung a Creed song.

No Paris or Chris should have won!

no! chris should have won no questions asked

No

no.taylor is more talented.

no