Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Do you feel there are too many religious questions on this site?

4 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Try the Church of the White Trash Americans

  • 1 decade ago

    Not necessarily, but there is too little listening. Also, there are too many irreverent questions. However, those also prove my point that there is too little listening.

  • 1 decade ago

    No, but I feel there are too many stupid, pointless ones. Have a great day!

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Super-Muslim: In or Out of Home?

    Keeping the Spirit Alive

    by Yahiya Emerick (see biography below)

    I just read a very interesting story. A teacher gave her students the

    following assignment: Ask a parent what their dream life was when they were

    a teenager, and then write an essay comparing it to your own dreams for

    your future right now. Accordingly, a teenager asked her mom about her

    aspirations when she was young, and the mother replied, (reflecting her

    Sixties hippie roots,) "I wished for a simple life, living on a farm

    commune, growing my own vegetables and being happy."

    The daughter paused for a moment and stopped writing down her mother’s

    words. "What’s wrong?" Her mother asked.

    "It’s sort of embarrassing," the teenager replied, "because all I want is

    to drive a Lexus and get a good job."

    In the first place, this may seem to be a harmless little story to elicit a

    chuckle. But it got me thinking. How many Muslim "activists" have I met,

    who spent all their free time doing Dawah and promoting Muslim causes, only

    to lose their own children and spouses to the kufr lifestyle? It’s pretty

    amazing that that would ever be the case. But I’ve seen it first hand and

    it isn’t pretty.

    Of the activist who is never home, we have no doubt about why he or she may

    lose their families. After all, THEY WERE NEVER HOME. We all know at least

    one person like this. Is it because it’s easier to be in the Masjid all

    day, surrounded by things that are easy to control, at least easier than an

    unruly child? Or has the activist become so filled with Islamic romaticism

    they live in a dreamland of khalifah, movements and spiritual battles? Only

    Allah knows for sure.

    But what about the other kind of activist? The one who is so skilled and

    full of energy that they can tear through any Dawah task outside the home

    and still have plenty of juice left over to "do Dawah" in the home. I’ve

    met quite a few of this category also. I’ve even taught the children of

    such "Super Da’ees" myself in the various Islamic schools I found myself

    in. Here are some interesting observations, but first, an introducing to

    the topic of giving Dawah in the home.

    Your hear a lot from people, from conventions, speeches, khutbas, etc…about

    the family being the number one priority for Dawah. Few speakers, however,

    give any realistic ways of doing it. It seems to me that the only method of

    "doing Dawah" that most people are familiar with is the challenge them/give

    a lecture format. In this format, one person assumes another is completely

    wrong. Then he or she proceeds to lecture them endlessly to bring the other

    person into enlightenment. Almost every Muslim activist I’ve ever met does

    this type of Dawah. Does it work? I’m usually the only convert at most

    gatherings I attend (male, at least). You decide.

    How does the super Da’ee relate Islam in his or her home? I will describe

    for you examples I’ve seen with my own eyes. A father and son come to my

    book table. The son is, by all standards, an Americanized teen. The father

    is an immigrant, middle-aged, Masjid-going and reasonably well-off

    financially. As the son is looking at the videos, the father endlessly

    lectures the son about why he should pray. It looks like a well-rehearsed

    script. The son’s face darkens in annoyance and he whispers, "You don’t

    understand." But the father, who is too busy lecturing on the merits of the

    prayer, didn’t hear him. I suspect he has probably never really heard his

    own son - ever.

    A mother with a loose, see-through head-scarf, precariously, (and

    obviously temporarily) perched on her permed hair, wearing the typical

    colorful get-up replete with nail polish and Gucci bag, is walking near the

    entrance to a Masjid during social gathering. Her teenage daughter is

    standing near her, wearing nail polish, make-up, tight, tight jeans, a

    short sleeve shirt and no head-covering at all. (Talk about dressed to

    attract!) A group of teenage "Muslim" boys walk by shouting and talking

    about sports and girls. This girl flirts with them and is about to follow

    them when the mother calls her daughter back and gives her a long lecture

    about why "Muslim girls shouldn’t hang out with boys alone.

    Here’s a favorite of mine: I know of a father who literally terrorizes his

    family with endless talk of Islam. To the point where pouring a cup of

    water in the home is to invite a lecture on the merits of water in Islam.

    Obviously, his children can’t stand Islam because they equate it with their

    father’s droning, boring and endlessly running voice.

    Each of the three examples has one common denominator: a parent who is

    forceful about giving some Islamic teaching, but who then goes about it the

    wrong way. The first parent never listened to his son, and instead, was

    totally unaware that his son was complete won over by modern, popular teen

    culture. If he would have developed a good relationship wit his son, and

    been a consistent role-model for him form his earliest memories, his son

    would have been praying all along. Lecturing a fifteen year old about

    prayer isn’t likely to make him want to start.

    The second parent didn’t follow Islamic requirements herself (and who knows

    what other Islamic deficiencies there were) and therefore didn’t encourage

    any sense of an Islamic identity in her daughter, at least as far as dress

    is concerned. Instead, she allowed her daughter to develop a completely

    non-Muslim style of fashion that apes the modern "liberated" woman who

    dresses only to be seen of men. Most probably her daughter hangs out with

    boys in her public high school everyday as well. If the mother allowed

    these un-Islamic habits to develop, then what good would all the forceful

    lectures do? Her daughter imagines herself to be a scantily clad beauty in

    a Madonna music video while her mother envisions her to be an Muslim

    princess ready for her marriage after eight years of college.

    And finally, one parent took Dawah to the extreme and made his family tired

    of Islam by his constant nagging. This is against Islam protocols of giving

    Dawah as even the prophet, himself, used to scold those who made people

    tired of too much "religious talk." Check out this topic and you’ll find

    many examples.

    So what’s the best way to give Dawah to your family? The wrong approaches,

    as highlighted before, include: not being open to your family members as

    individual people with thoughts and feelings, being insincere or a

    hypocrite and finally, going overboard.

    The right way to do Dawah in you home is to start with yourself first. You

    could literally spend your whole life working on your own faith and actions

    without even talking to anyone else! You are the first priority in Dawah.

    Are you sincere? Are you being true to yourself. Do you know something is

    bad but then do it anyway?

    What do you know about Islam? Is it possible that you may harbor feelings

    of racism, hypocrisy or un-Islamic cultural traditions from your upbringing?

    People know who is real. A popular American novel entitled, ‘The Catcher in

    the Rye," has, as its main theme, a disillusioned young boy in a world full

    of hypocrites. All he wants is to meet someone who is "genuine" and not a

    "phony". Your own children know if you’re real or not. And it’s sad to say,

    but it’s almost always true: the manners and attitudes of the child are an

    uncamouflaged reflection of what is in the deepest heart of the parents.

    Whatever is hidden in the core of your heart will come out loud and clear

    in their demeanor and attitudes. If your kids are not so good Islamically,

    be afraid of your own soul.

    If you’re living as a true Muslim, not a perfect one, but a trying one,

    then everyone sees it in your manners, speech and behavior. You’re not yet

    saying a word to anyone, but you’re giving Dawah. The best Dawah is not

    words- it’s actions, it’s attitude, it’s genuine. Knowledge of Islam is not

    to be measured in how many du’as a person knows or surahs memorized. Even

    parrots can be taught to say surahs but no one puts kufis or hijabs on

    their feathered heads. Islamic knowledge is displayed in what no spoken

    word can say. If you’re around a good-hearted person, you can feel it. You

    want to be around that person more and to do what they do and to be like them.

    Have you ever wondered why everyone wanted to be so close to the blessed

    Prophet? Iman, goodness and wisdom emanated from him. Think of people in

    your life who had these qualities about them. One student told me his

    grandfather was the sweetest Muslim ever. A girl told me her mother was her

    Islamic role model. A bunch of kids in a class named the local Arabic

    expert as their favorite teacher to be around. What were the qualities in

    all three of these individuals? None f them ever lectured anybody. (I’ve

    met and known all three.) One was a hafiz, one a homemaker/Islamic activist

    and the other a scholar. But when you met them, they often said very little

    about Islam directly and they certainly didn’t lecture or come off as

    arrogant.

    What united all of them was that they were real sincere believers. So it’s

    not how many "study-circles" you hold with your family, it’s not how many

    surahs you make your children memorize. It’s not even sending your children

    to a Sunday school or an Islamic school that is the key. Rather, the key is

    you.

    If you’re trying, sincere Musilm, you don’t talk too much- about anything-

    and you perform good deeds as secretly as possible and you try to be as

    peaceful and helpful to others as you can without asking anything in

    return. (You also take your pleasure in simple things, not expensive

    vacations and lavish living.) You prefer others over yourself and you don’t

    display your wealth or worldly success by accumulating the finest cars,

    homes and clothes. Anything else is folly and you’ll pay for it one day. A

    good guidebook to Islamic humilty is called, "God-Oriented Life" by

    Wahiduddin Khan. It contains the most beautiful hadith/Sahaba advice I’ve

    ever seen.

    Don’t be a Muslim "activist" if all your activity is going to be outside

    the home. And don’t be an Islamic "terror" to your family: coming in like a

    whirlwind, from time-to-time, upsetting the normal schedule of everyone,

    even if you’re enraged by what you see your family doing. Because if your

    family is doing things that are not good Islamically, then where were you

    all those years when those things were being built up in their minds and

    habits. A series of lectures or thrashings on your part won’t change their

    attitudes.

    Only when others see Islam make a meaningful change in your life will they

    be willing to try the same. That is the real Dawah to the family, that is

    the only message that they will listen to and the only way to make Islam

    survive in your family tree. Think about it.

    ------------------------------------

    Yahiya Emerick has been a prolific author and has written many articles

    that have been published in local as well as national magazines, both in

    North America and abroad. Amirah Publishing was founded by Yahiya Emerick

    in 1992 in order to further his ideal of publishing American-oriented

    literature on Islam. Much to his chagrin, Brother Yahiya found that many

    traditional Muslims were quite content with the old, outdated books

    imported from overseas and could not conceive of the need for literature

    specifically designed for the North American environment.

    After having written two books, which received wide acclaim in local Muslim

    circles, Brother Yahiya looked in vain for a publisher willing to work with

    him in this vision. After many promises and vague arrangements, he decided

    to form his own company and work for Allah as best he knew how. Today, with

    the addition of Reshma Baig, Qasim Najar and Samina Baig to the team,

    Amirah Publishing is enjoying rapid growth and recognition among Muslims as

    a source for original, as well as improved literature, for use in a

    strictly American environment.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.