Who sucks more: Jimmy Buffett or John Mellencamp?

Buffett.....I'd like to tell him where to put the shaker of salt....when he finds it

John "Cougar" Mellancamp does more...cause Buffett at least has cool parties going on in the parking lot before his shows

his fans are real fanatics...that's what that fogie has going for him

John "Cougar" Mellancamp is a joke, with songs like "Cherry Bomb"...even Springsteen is cooler than him...

dude, **** off

neither suck, john mellencamp is an intelligent song writer and jimmy buffet is just fun music, good time stuff not elevator "muzak" get your head out of your *** and dont ask about which rock artist sucks more in the rock and pop section, dick head

Jimmy Buffet songs drive me crazy even when I am drunk, I can't stand him. But then again I really cringe every time "Jack and Diane" is on, tha song is so horrible! Still I think I hate Buffet more.

Gonna go with Buffet.. I think that Margarittaville song is all the explaination I need.

Since I AM a fan of John Mellencamp's, I'd have to say Jimmy Buffet, although I kinda like him, too. Ever hear his song "Why Don't We Get Drunk and Screw"?....it's an oldie - and it's HILARIOUS!!!

John Mellencamp, Jimmy Buffet isn't that bad... listen to him.... he isn't elevator "muzak"

I agree... Buffet sucks

JOHN MELLENCAMP IS AWESOME...I DO ADMIT JIMMY BUFFET DOES ACT SORTTA WELL GAY...SORTTA LIKE KENNY CHESNEY...SO I'M GONNA SAY...JIMMYBUFFET!!!!!!

As a Parrothead I say Mellencamp sucks....

.....just as much as madcap does. LOL