Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

How did our US culture become so polarized and politicized?

Our answer board is dominated by answerers who appear to know the absolute truth on politics, religion, the war, and many of our societal matters—often backed by ad hominum attacks like "the holder of such and such an opinion is an idiot". How did we get this way? Is it media bias, or the bias of our educators? Is it a matter of the perspective of age and/or education? Have we somehow lost the social dedication that our WWII citizens had? Is it the fall of general religious belief and the rise of MTV narcissism? Is it an extension of our legal system where the truth doesn't really matter but only the best or most unassailable argument that counts? What happened to the idea that there is at least a kernal of truth in any professed opinion? We ask questions, and if not leaving them for the the voters to decide, often select the answer that matches our preconception, so the question was not really a question. I don't know the answer to this and am interested in hearing your opinions

Update:

Dr Trevor—I gave you a thumbs up and then watched "Zeitgeist". You, sir, are part of the problem—your use of this film contradicted most of your assertions except your stated idea about evil big business. Part 1 was interesting mythologically which might, if true, offend only the strictest literal bible believers. Parts 2&3 did exactly the opposite of what your film championed. It used edited video and an authoritarian tone as a substitute for truth. I have read counter-point in detail to most of what was presented there. It is a shame that more of our young don't read and, instead, plug into such a video. Let me give you and your hypocrisies a written thumbs down!!

Update 2:

I found much food for thought in your answers. I am closing the question today because I will be away; there have not been recent contributors; and I wanted to be able to further respond to you all. I do think that human nature plays a role—we are binary by nature: right-left; male-female; yes-no; etc. Cliques, too, are human nature: us and them. There have been political and theological wars, but they seemed to have had leaders. Our societal moves seem, at once, more accelerated and more diffuse to me—we are more rapidly adrift, settling for things to blame without recognizing the problem. I think the ideas of the influence of the internet and increased communication capacity, as well as the influence (and distrust) of the media are significant—they do lead to over-load and escapism. All good points! Except for the Rome and Nero comment (about which I know too little), I must select the answer by Theophilus which implied a creeping loss of standards. I will now have a drink and chill.

17 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    A lot of things have changed our country.

    1. We have watered down our educational system.

    2. We have been fed the line that we are what is important.

    3. We have been a sheltered generation that knows no strife.

    4. We have been taught that you can beat the system.

    5. We have a political system that has run amok.

    6. We have a court system that has run amok.

    It is the combination of all these things that has created the world that we live in today.

    Our government has done all it can to remove religion from public discussion.

    We are being taught to a good extend by the hippies of the sixties in many of our colleges.

    Our country is becoming much like Rome in the days of Nero.

    grace2u

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Escapism, distraction, excessive obligation, and laziness.

    Most of us are overworked by corporation that, instead of hiring more people, they simply dump the work onto the existing employees without raising pay.

    From there, we go home exhausted. We don't want to watch about the deaths and violence in the world (which is all the news talks about). So, we watch The Simple Life or other mindless entertainment to escape our reality.

    And that's only when we don't have to clean the house, pay the bills, take the kids to ________ practice, work out, cook dinner, etc.

    All of this obligation and escapism takes away any interest in intellectual pursuit. For instance, if you ask people to look at their beliefs from a logical perspective, very few would know how to do that. They wouldn't understand, and they wouldn't know where to start. With such a monumental task, they find it overwhelming, and give up before they start.

    We exist to survive, and in the U.S., we need money to survive. With the poverty rate at $8 an hour, we need to get educated and stay current to make enough to survive. But the education we receive has little to nothing to do with anything beyond surviving in the corporate world.

    Students at colleges are not interested in intellectual pursuit. They want a degree because they want a job that pays well. Of the students I teach, I'd say fewer than 5% are in college to learn anything. They simply want the degree. And colleges are catering to that. I have to argue with my students about the relevance of what I teach (composition and critical thinking). They believe that neither are practical, so the knowledge is useless.

    For example, in my critical thinking class, I teach the classical forms of logical argument. I have had several students say, "No one actually uses this type of thinking, so there's no point in learning it." I look at them and say, "If you are content not being a critical thinker, that is your business."

    I could go on and on, but I recognize the struggle on both ends. I try hard to stay informed on major issues, but I simply don't have the time to read as many news sources as I would like. On top of that, I get angry and depressed after I read the news. I've gotten so angry that I've almost stopped reading the news. I'm tired of reading about politicians who pit voters against one another. It's disgusting.

    I'll stop there. Bleh.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I think it's the Internet. I love the net of course. Best invention ever. But, it has it's pitfalls as it is a very effective means of getting information to people, whether for good or bad.

    To clarify, some of the most outspoken, opinionated people are posting on the net. There is very little of the middle of the road being represented. It begins to feel like there is no middle.

    For example, I never knew I was a hippie, communist, God-hating homeschooling freak until I read about it on the net. Problem is, as an atheist homeschooler and a democrat and wife of a soldier, I'm not really sure what "side" I'm supposed to be on. I am sure eventually someone will tell me.

  • 1 decade ago

    Dude,all of us would be baffled if we all admitted just how much the media,TV,movies,and man's philosophy dictates how people feel and think.Personally I don't trust the news we all read on the Internet.The media has a bad habit of showing nothing but the bad stuff anymore,and they dwell on personalities that I would bet most of us don't give a hill of beans about.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    This is a deep question and you have many good points.

    I will attempt to provide a short itemized list of causes. You can decide for yourself whether or not they are true. You can also decide for yourself how many of them are accidental and natural and how many of them are at least possibly intentional and manufactured.

    Television:

    …mostly provides distraction ( sports, titillation and fluff) not educational material.

    People are encouraged to root for their favorite teams. In fact, they often foster violent demonstrations of rampant centrism, based on locality or some other irrational allegiance.

    TV often capitalizes on stereotypes for villains in plot. So do modern movies which feature enemies as separate protagonists, (people or groups) instead of focusing on conceptual enemies such as ignorance, greed or dishonesty.

    News propaganda supports "us against them" ideals. Muslim vs. Christian, black vs. White, Nationals vs. immigrants, good vs. evil etc.

    School serves to indoctrinate not educate.

    Children learn to make derisive commentary about others in social settings like school.

    Children are forced to attend school ( a social setting) before they have the maturity to recognize human similarities far outweigh racial or social differences.

    Politicians:

    …divide people into groups for campaigning and making special laws.

    Political parties divide people into conservative and liberal groups for the purpose of divisive arguments and motivation.

    Business:

    …divides people into groups based on their usefulness to the business and treats most people as expendable commodities.

    Huge global corporations take advantage of groups based on their economic hardship, local political corruption and race.

    Social acceptance is often based on highly divisive materialistic recognition; the “haves” vs. the “have-nots.”

    Most of these can be seen as merely a by product of global competition. They can also be viewed as intentional crimes perpetrated by an elite group of profiteering bankers hell-bent on world domination. I will not express an opinion here because it is impossible to prove in such a limited format.

    However, if you would like to learn more in a very entertaining and informative format, just go to Google videos and search for the movie, “Zeitgeist.”

    It is in three parts, each as edifying as the next. The production value is good, the music is good and the facts are irrefutable. Watch it. Tell others.

    Zeitgeist, has many answers that you seek.

  • 1 decade ago

    I think its human nature to be clique-ish when it comes to politics and religion. Look at all the wars that have been fought throughout history. How many were fought over something other than politics or religion?

  • 1 decade ago

    I think that you are thinking way too hard for a friday dude. The weekend is here sit back have a drink and chill.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    let's face it. in the categories of religion, philosophy, society, and politics, most of the questions are just rephrased opinions anyway. people aren't really looking for hard answers, like they are in other sections like cooking and cars. they're looking to reinforce their own views and converse with people who share them. and they're hoping some idiot who thinks otherwise will respond so their faithful like-thinkers will shower him or her with negative ratings. it's just the nature of debating things like this and seeing how your view fares in the face of the opponent. it doesn't surprise me at all.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    When has America ever been anything but polarized and politicized? That's part of what makes it great. Freedom to express differing views.

  • ?
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    The Ego and Pride of each individual

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.