For True Harry Potter fans to answer.?

Question

Spoiler! (do not read further if not finished book 7.  Ok, In book 7 the trio does not return to Hogwarts until late in the book.  Even under the regime of the Carrows and snape the sorting was still done.  I would like you to tell me what msg you believe that the Sorting hat gave before the sorting in book 7.  Usually the hat gave a warning or told them to unite.  I would like to know what it might have said under this regime.  Would the msg be the same? How would it change.  All answers are correct and there is not a bad answer.  Please do your best and I will pick th best in a days time.

ghost · Accepted Answer

if your anything but a slytherin you may as well be prepared, for the end is coming and sooner than your aware
 some of you may wish a syltherin to be.
 you think this is the winning team!
but never fear for i the Winning Sorting hat  will place you faithfully to you rightful side as you deserve to be.
 Courage, Strength and Loyalty will have their day.

Samantha · Answer

I would imagine the sorting hat, for once, remained silent. I don't think it gave a speach/warning. The hat is always interested in the well being of Hogwarts, but saying too much and letting the enemy hear it would not be good. I think it knew what was up, and thought it best not to let anything be known to those who shouldn't be listening.
It would be kind of strange for it to tell Hogwarts to 'stand together', etc. When part of the people who would be dangerous to it were already inside!! I think that's why J.K. Rowling didn't write that part.....because the hat always made a speach....but this time, it would be strange for it to, so she left it out and didn't mention it.

kingelessar2 · Answer

I think it would be the same. It was obviously what happened, minus the participation of Slytherin, if you don't count Snape and Slughorn. 

The entire school united to get rid of the threat that "threatened" everything Hogwarts was about. That "prophecy" if you want to see it like that was succeeded when at the end, the house tables are no longer seen as such. Everyone was sitting amongst eachother. It was only with their combined efforts was Volde and his crew defeated...and also...all the prejudices of the Wizarding World, which was what kept Volde in power. That's why the good guys won. They finally overcame what kept them apart. Blood and family no longer mattered. They ttok away what gave Volde his power, and he lost. 

If anything, the Hat made it sound even more important.

justasking · Answer

Hi!
This is a really great question!!!

I do think that the hat would have stuck to his message of Unity. Hands down.
Remember that the Hat was Gryffindor's so, it is not like he was scared of any Slytherin.
He probably used some strange words (like Pinocchio does in Shrek, I mean - pardon for the comparison), but to me it stuck to his message.
Probably then they gave him a beating, but nothing that a 1000 year-old hat can't handle.

Goodluck!

LizzWeasley · Answer

It probably would have been something like "Unite again. That way we can succeed.." Or something like that.

Trending News

For True Harry Potter fans to answer.?

5 Answers