Okay everyone, tell me what you think about this Edward Cullen casting?

You know I saw the magazine today and thought the same exact thing...i mean look at this photo i think he could pull it off i mean he even has the crooked smile

http://i23.photobucket.com/albums/b361/soccercutie...

Oh God.

I honestly would stop reading the books if that happened.

If Zac Efron wasn't so popular, and if he wasn't in a cheesy movie that spreads bad messages disguised as good ones (e-mail me for those messages) and if he actually SANG (his voice is mixed) and if he wasn't on every tween girl's bedroom wall, then maybe.

He does have some talent. And he is cute. But he's not Edward.

Speaking of Zac Efron, I'm having an anti-HSM 2 party today...

urgh! i would absolutely refuse to see the movies if he got casted! he's too full of light to be edward...does that make sense to you? edward is supposed to be hard like granite and super pale....zac efron just does not do edward justice. i think we're gonna have to hope that a nobody gets casted into edward's role....i'd be so disappointed if they did someone famous who just didnt fit the part exactly. but then again i am picky about my favorite books becoming movies...

i wont see the harry potter movies because i've read the books a total of 48 times and dont want to ruin the image that i've got in my head. maybe the twilight series will have to be the same way...

hmm I think his face is too round, too babyish good looks. I could see him as one of the humans, but not edward.

sorry, but i just don't picture him as Edward.... he's going to be the hardest part to cast too because everyone has their own view of him... besides that, I'm really anixious to see who they do cast!!

I think he's too boyish. They need to cast someone who is young, but who doesn't look too much like a fresh-face kid.

no i dont think that he'll fit the part as edward. hes to tan.

nah, he would look better playing the part of jacob.....maybe. but he is cute in that pic lol