TOP CHEF FANS, What did you think of Tre being eliminated ?

that's it for top chef!!!!!! of all the chef's to send home, they send home tre????? they must be out of their natural gourmet eating, bs spitting, high falutting minds!!!! here you have howie.. who has been messing up from day one.... and his sweaty a** is still around. brian, who obviously did not contribute and hold up his end in the challenge.... is still around. and don't get me started on "cj"... that no talent, back stabbing, chef wannabe!! have they all lost their minds!! i can't wait to get the bravo website and rip somebody a new one!!! have a nice day =)

I was shocked. Tre is a billion times better than Casey and Sara. I can't wait for Casey and Sara both to be sent home. Neither are good chefs and they don't contribute any entertainment value to the show.

I thought Tre might be the one to win the show but now I guess it's an open field. I'm cheering for Dale.

I am not completely surprised. The team competitions are the toughest since you are dependent not only on your own skill but on the skills of your teammates. Tre was in the leadership position for his team which meant that in a close call, he was in the most vulnerable position.

Because of the rules of the overall competition (that each event is judged separately), it is hard to tell who will ultimately win as anyone can be eliminated by one bad week. Howie and Hung look like the people currently holding the Tiffany/Marcel slot as the ones that annoy others the most. As the producers have some input into decisions, that would tend to indicate that one of them may be pulled into the final 3 or 4 even if they should go whom earlier just to keep the pot boiling as far as personality conflicts.

I thought Tre was the best chef besides Howie and everybody thinks howie is horrible but, he can cook and that is what matters. I thought it was going to be Howie vs. Tre. Now it is going to be Howie vs. Casey. Sara sucks period. Cj sucks he doesnt know how to work with people in a productive manner he wants people to like him. Hung is the Marcel of the show and being kept around for ratings. Brian won't win because everytime he makes something by himself he takes seafood cook some damn meat. My god. He is horrible and boring. Dale is good and might go to the end. But if howie can work well with people he will win. I think he is the best. He doesn't take crap and judging show by show is gay. I think they should judge like hells kitchen judge by what they have done. It just makes sense if your looking for a top chef you are looking for someone who is good and consistent over time just because they have one bad day means nothing. I mean who is Colicchio to be judging he makes a steak worth 50 bucks that is only worth 10 at most it was horrible. He is an ***. Padma is hot and should have her own show and maybe colicchio should take on the winners after the last show. Tom, Padma, Gail, and Ted . Should take on Ilan, Harold and winner of top chef 3.

so disappointed and sad to see Tre go- the judges have said that it's that one performance they base their judgement on and with that criteria Tre had to go.

however i think CJ, Casey and Brian really let him down. i think they trusted him too much and not enough in themselves and gave over to him b/c of his experience. no responsibility taken so therefore no consequences. they'll get theirs i hope soon!

BTW, did you know that Tre was a James Beard rising star nominee? check out the Jame beard foundation website

Tre is apprently doing well though according to Collicio's blong on TC so that's good.

I will miss him, his cool, confident and mature demeanor made him a class act. and unlike some of the others eliminated he took responisbility and didn't blame anyone and didn't cop out like Mich and Sara by saying bascially they were too good for this competition or that they weren't nasty enough to survive. they lost b/c they sucked.

Tre lost b/c perhaps he was too relaxed and b/c his team sucked too.

extremely pissed..Tre was my favorite..he was the man and to me one of the best chef's..he messed up in one episode and gets the boot..but now i think Brian wins..only reason Casey's still there is b/c she's attractive..sara stinks..hung is too out of control but is a good chef..howie will blow a fuse b4 the season is over..CJ is gonna get his head stuck in the ceiling and will have to forfeit..I like Dale but i have a feeling he's gonna hit a bump in the road like Tre did and get eliminated..but i think it will be between CJ and Brian in the end.

i was really surpised actually. My jaw literally dropped when they said his name. I thought that he had been consistently good throughout the show. I thought he was going to be in the top 3. Now it's hard to say who will win. I think maybe Hung or Dale will win. Hung is annoying as hell, but he puts out good food. I would want Dale to win now that Tre is out. Dale also is pretty consistent with his food.

this season has totally sucked! I thought for sure that Tre was going to take the cake at the end of this season. Now I just dont know who will win it. It seems to me that its fifty fifty for everyone now. Oh well. But I guess I will still continue to watch it

It was totally unfair! He made three dishes, the others made one and theirs were all bad. Who salts a lobster? That's insane!

They didn't show how they came to that conclusion but it was wrong.

I think he accepted it like a true gentleman that he is. I hope he does open his own restaurant and has a lot of success with it.

Maybe Hung will win or Sara. I just don't know any more.

sure easily! i'm besides the incontrovertible fact that a sprint disillusioned to no longer see Sam as between the chefs. and that i'd have enjoyed to have seen Hung and Marcel in opposition with one yet another! yet you spot i'm hooked in this tutor so i'd be gazing no remember who they threw in that kitchen!