Edgerrin James or Maurice Jones-Drew?

keep pocket hercules. he has the better line in jacksonville, and james plays for the cardinals who might have rattay starting as their qb, so they might wear him out and he may not be able to produce or he may get injured with increased carries.

Honestly, its consistency versus explosiveness. Edge will provide you consistent numbers while MJD will go for the homeruns every game. The only problem is that Edge will probably face tougher defenses as teams dare the backup QB to beat them down field.

I'd trade Edge (plus the fact that he's older and a little more likely to get hurt than MJD).

I say MJD, catch him on the up swing and maybe you can just use him to get Chad Johnson. MJD will still share carries and I doubt he will ever have another game like last weekend again. Edge is the only RB for AZ he would be more consistent. So it's up to, MJD is more of a risk-reward running back.

I would trade Edgerrin because he doesn't have the team around him that Maurice does.

i like the trade but i get nervous with Chad, the bangles seem to have there little problems and Palmer and Chad keep bumping heads i would rather get T.J. and just Trade James and one of the other wr's

Do you need to trade one? If you have flex positions in your league I definitely would not do it. Either way, it seems to me like you're giving up way too much to get OchoCinco.

Definitely get Ocho Cinco if you can, He's ALWAYS a fantasy stud

Jones Drew, he is prolific this year.