When will people realize that Eli...........?

I'd say he's an above average QB and would be better than that if given the same situation that Peyton was given. No disrespect meant on the Giants, but they aren't exactly the best football program in the NFL. And their coach is a nutcase. His teammates are some of the most selfish in the sport and they aren't really cohesive.

Put Eli in the same spot Tom Brady has and then we can decide what kind of QB he is. I understand what you are saying, but I wouldn't give up on him yet.

You try playing when you're carrying "Peyton Manning's Brother" on your back.

Eli has struggled in the second half of seasons throughout his career so far. So, it wasn't a surprise to see those delay-of-game pennalties, etc.

He struggles during the second half of seasons, but I would say he's an average/above average quarterback at times. Though, he doesn't seem to be able to bring his team back when it counts.

Yea...he sucks...It killed me to play him in my fantasy football this week as I'm used to murdering ppl with Tom Brady...Eli Manning sucks and if New York ever wants to do something with their team they need to concentrate on their running game as they have 2 very talented RB's and could do some damage if their D stepped it up a bit...Not to mention Plaxico would be amazing if he had a guy who could give him the ball (Look what happened to Randy Moss)

Eli wasn't the worst manning this week

Eli and Payton are both overrated

they both get over because of the other guys on the team

when the season is over they both Will go home to Louisiana to cry to their dad

The Cowboys had penalties too? What game where you watching? The Cowboys secondary getting stronger and stronger and where not even healthy man. DALLAS HAD MORE PENALTY YARDS IN THE GAME

When they realize his first name is Eli not Peyton who is also overrated

I dont know but its making me sick and I wish everyone would realize it. GOOD LORD!