Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Help I have a transmission problem?
I have an automatic 2000 Saturn SC 2. I had my oil changed and ever since then my Service Engine Soon light has been going on and off. I had the codes run at Auto Zone. It came up a transmission problem. The car runs, and the fluid is fine. A few times it has not worked right. I have been backing up, then changing to drive and it was not changing over. It then would make a loud noise and then kick into drive. I have recently moved and don't have a garage and being a girl I am a little nervous to find one to fix my problem. I do have an AAMCO about 15 minutes away but I can't bring it in until Friday. Any ideas of what this might be and what it's gonna cost me??
I had the transmission fluid changed in April of last year. I know to change the oil in my car you have to take off a plate. I'm not sure...but I know because otherwire I would do it myself. I am hesitant to go back to this place that did my oil change. Although my boyfriends family does their stuff there, which is why I went, I just don't feel comfortable there. I guess I'll see what AAMCO comes up with from their free diagnostic testing.
12 Answers
- 77ImpalaLv 51 decade agoFavorite Answer
Might look underneath the car for a disconnected plug on the transmission. It may be that when the oil was changed someone accidentally knocked a plug connection off. This transmission may have computer connection and without it, it may cause your problem. It is worth a look anyway to be sure. And may save you some major headache and cash.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Check your transmission fluid level. It was very common for maintenance techs on those Saturns to mistakenly drain the transmission, rather than the engine, when doing an oil change. The reason for that is a mix of inexperience, as well as ,when you are under that car and looking up at the engine and transmission, your transmission takes a filter that looks exactly like an oil filter. I have seen many many general service techs see the filter on the transmission side and assume that is the engine, and pull the drainplug on the transmission. The oil filter is actually hidden above the drive axle, and is rather small. It is most likely, someone pulled the wrong drainplug, and rather than fess up, they put the plug back in and sent you on your way. If this is not the case, AAMCO starts at about 1783.00 for a base overhaul, and from there, depends on what hard parts have to be replaced. Usually ends up around 2500.00 with a 3 year/50k warranty. I would check the transmission fluid level before driving it, and also call the shop that changed your oil. I think your problem will be fixed with a few quarts of transmission fluid.
- SocksLv 41 decade ago
Sounds like a slipping transmission. When you check your transmission fluid level smell the dip stick. If the fluid smells burnt then this is probably your problem...
You have a burnt out shift band. You'll have to replace the shift band, and while you're at it you'll probably want to install a rebuild kit - new clutch plates and gaskets etc. A pretty expensive job, probably around $1000.
Before you go and get it rebuilt, double check that your transmission fluid is clean and at the proper full level. Your engine should be running when you check your transmission fluid; some transmissions require you to be in park, others in neutral when you check the fluid level. Make sure the fluid is a bright and clear pink color and doesn't have any metal flakes or dirt or other particulates in it. If it does seem dark or have stuff in it or smells burnt, you might try getting a transmission flush. This shouldn't cost more than $100 and may clear up your problem. Otherwise you're probably in for the rebuild.
Most decent tranny shops will do a free test drive to see what your problem is before they'll give you a quote on service. Some will also top off your fluid level for free too. Chances are you'll be OK driving it for a while so long as you don't shift too hard or too fast from reverse into drive, this can actually break the internal gears in your transmission. Depending on how much you've invested in the car and how long you plan to keep it, you might just drive it until the transmission dies completely. I drove my last car for 3 years with a burnt out shift band and a fluid leak - I had no 2nd gear and shifted from 1st straight into 3rd. It still drove when I traded it in on my new car. Of course I only paid $300 for it, so it wasn't worth trying to fix.
:edit:
Another thing I just thought of - there ARE different types of transmission fluids, and they are not all compatible with each other and don't all work in all transmissions. If they topped off your tranny fluid with a different kind of transmission fluid than what you already had in it, that can cause some serious problems - but SHOULD be fixable with a good full service flush (not just a fluid replacement, but a complete flush of the transmission).
- 5 years ago
I don't see anything in your comments that points at the transmission other than for some reason you got that in your head. Get your fuel filter changed and ask the mechanic if you can watch him do it. The fuel filter is cheap but you are going to pay for a minimum one hour shop time $50 - $70. As for the fuel gauge, the only thing wrong is you expecting it to work with a couple gallons in the tank. They are set to have a couple gallons left when it reads near empty. That's when you sucked up a bunch of crap, plugged the filter and killed the engine. Transmissions don't like dead engines when they are in gear, so they start talking. I say ask to watch the fuel filter change because after this you can do it yourself. Lesson 1: Watch how the wrenches are applied so the fuel line is not twisted. Lesson 2: Watch how the mechanic handles the spillage of gas when it is removed. Lesson 3: Ask the mechanic to show you all the crap you sucked up driving on empty.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- Doug WLv 61 decade ago
Hi. We have a 2002 Saturn SL2. We have the same problem. Your check engine code will surely come up as no first gear problem. The computer knows that it isn't going forward in first gear. When this happens, don't rev the engine so that it bangs hard when it goes in gear. If you just wait, then you won't break anything. The problem is either the oil pump seal or the first gear sprag. Usually the seal is bad. usually rebuild is the most common thing since it has quite a few miles.
Source(s): Fixed them before. Happened on a 1970 ford truck too. Nothing to do with electronic transmissions. - 1 decade ago
It COULD be a linkage problem if they messed it up somehow.
Have someone check the linkage from the handle to the tranny and you might want to service the transmission for good measure if it has been a while.
meaning just change the fluid, filter, gasket, and I don't know if that car would need to change the modulator or not they usually cost more.
that Service without the modulator is like $50 - $70 maybe more, should be less.
If you have more severe damage it get expensive quick.
$200 and up
- 1 decade ago
one thing when changing gears the car should be at a complete stop ( from reverse to drive) if you don't this will damage your tranmission. sounds to me like the transmission has already been damaged.the bands or ports sound to me to be damaged.if you have to replace your transmission you have a few options.don't buy a new transmission,go with a rebuilt or a used one
- Anonymous1 decade ago
If it's very expensive, get a second opinion. I've heard some bad things about AAMCO.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
first check the fluid level in the transmission, if you don't know Howe ,ask someone to show you,this can happen if fluid level is low,if this is not the problem take it to a dealer unless you know someone who will recommend a local mechanic
Source(s): self - friedachLv 61 decade ago
which oil changed motor or transmission? if transmission, was it adjusted too? if so, he might have got it wrong, and he needs to get it right. engine check light-could be bad wiring, or not reset properly.