Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

How Often Do You Buy CDs by Bands/Artists You've Never Heard?

Do you ever buy a band's/artist's album(s) without having ever heard any of their songs, or do you have to have heard at least some of their material before you'll fork over the cost of the CD?

If you do, what is it that compels you to buy those CDs, and what was the last such CD you bought, and how well did taking the chance on it work out for you?

For me, I do it often enough, although not as often as I used to. Most of the it's time because of a recommendation someone gives me, or because the band in question is generally well thought of. On rare occasions, I'll just take a chance on someone I've never heard of, or get the album because of the label it's on.

Update:

The best example or this type of buying working out for me was when I saw "The End of History" by Fionn Regan in a record shop sometime in '06. I hadn't heard of him, but the cover caught my eye, and I noticed that he was on Damien Rice's label, Heffa, so I got the album, and it's now one of my all-time favourites.

Morning Darth, although it's already the afternoon here :)

Update 2:

Hey Sookie, thanks. I should be studying for my exams right now, which started on Friday, but I'm too easily distracted, as you can see :P

Like you, I think it is the case that with bills and my college fees and such, I can't really afford to take any chances on CDs, lol.

Hope you're having a less boring weekend than me, studying sucks :)

Update 3:

Hi Jake. Yeah, I know what you mean, but sometimes you can't resist an impulse buy in a record shop. Especially when putting it off so you can check it out on the web means waiting a week or more until you have another chance to get to the shops.

Update 4:

Hey Huevo. Picking up "Surfer Rosa" has got to be one of the best impules buys ever.

Update 5:

Hey Mach :)

I totally agree with you, the label a band is signed to can be a great way gauge the chance you have of liking them. My favourites would probably be Sub Pop, Asthmatic Kitty, Jagjaguwar...

From what I'm seeing here, it seems like the availability of music on the web has played a big part in doing away with record store impulse buys. Kind of a shame, although understandable.

34 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Hey Rukrym!

    Oh, I do. And I will have to agree it's a "label" thing. If even two or three of my favorite bands are already signed under that label, chances are, other bands on that label will be just as original, or good. So, that's a very good point you brought up. On occasion, I'll admit also -- I'll purchase a CD on impulse if the album's title, or a few of the song titles just strike me as interesting (as I'm walking around a record store). To me, that's already a sign of good song-writing. Maybe that's silly. But I haven't been wrong. I did that with the first Belle & Sebastian album I bought: "The Boy with The Arab Strap". I've been a collector of their albums since. edit: But like everyone else, I've been doing my music purchases a lot more online lately.

    edit: Yes! Sub Pop is a definite favorite. Also, alien8recordings, Jade Tree records, and Empty Records

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I don't do that very often, but I have bought many many many of my albums based on only hearing one track, and I haven't really been disappointed yet. Here are some albums I bought before hearing the band:

    -The Compleat Eater - Eater

    -Generation X - Generation X

    -(I'm) Stranded - The Saints

    -Go Girl Crazy - The Dictators

    -Don't Push Me Around - The Zeros

    -Weird World Vol. 1 - The Weirdos

    --(For the above two and Eater I had heard low quality 30 second sound clips from one song each, so cross them off if that counts)--

    -Greatest Hits Vol. 1 (1964-1966) - The Yardbirds

    And actually that looks like it. I'm still not opposed to the idea, but a lot of the times before I buy a CD someone sends me a track or two. Personally if I'm pretty sure I'm going to like a CD, I don't want to hear it before I buy it. Because when I first started buying CD's I had been real big into downloading so I'd have heard most or all of theCD before and it was nice it had better quiality and I love liner notes and having the music as a physical entity, but there was no surprise. So now if I plan on buying a band's CDs I avoid them like the plague so when I buy the music it's all fresh and new.

  • I do. I buy around 4 or 5 CDs a week so it'd be too time-consuming to seek them all out, and a lot of them are obscure. It's the only way to truly familiarise yourself with new styles and genres. It's incredible, the number of albums I've listened to once and thought they were no good, only for it to become one of my favourite albums. Or had a change of heart about an album years later. Perhaps that's why I do it, because I know from experience it can work. It allows to have an extremely diverse collection of music; surely you'd just get bored if you kept buying music that was 'safe'? I can't be that pensive. If I see a record I think I might buy in a record store, I do it, I don't have to go home and research the bloody thing. I'll assess it for myself, and if I don't like, at least I've experienced something from it.

    Take reading for example, very rarely have people read even a small fragment of a book before they buy it. They go purely by critical opinion, past experiences and interests in the content. I just apply the same philosophy to music. I've no prejudices about genre and am open to anything. A name dropped on a forum*, a band name you like the sound of...it could be your knew favourite band.

    I guess I can afford to do this because I spend a large proportion of my discretionary income on music. I've got 2000+ CDs.

    *Montag mentioned RateYourMusic. The quality of the lists/diversity of opinions is excellent there.

  • 1 decade ago

    Normally, I have to have heard either a song or two, or several 30 second samples of songs.

    But I did buy without hearing the 4 Rainbow albums I bought.

    I bought the 1995 album because I knew Candice Night had co-written most of the lyrics, and the first 3 original albums based on Darth Maul's song recommendations.

    And it all started because I got into Blackmore's Night!

    The '95 album is great, and so far I've listened to a bit of the first of the other albums, and for the most part, I like what I hear :)

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Well, usually, a new album by a band, they release a single first which usually reveals the "style" of the album. Sometimes, the rest of the tracks can be completely different though! I will listen to a couple of the songs I don't know, but not them all, because I wouldn't want to spoil the album.

    The next album I'm going to buy is the new Bullet For My Valentine album, - Scream Aim Fire. I have heard two of the songs from it, one being a single. It sounds awesome, so I'll be sure to buy the album!

    I guess there's a lot more I could say, but that should answer it.

  • 1 decade ago

    How it's happened so far: if its a band I am unfamiliar with but have recented a good recommendation, my brother'll (he is music director a radio station) have the cd for me to copy.

    And there are some albums that I've never heard anything off of, but liked the band's other album/s, so i'll pick it up (such as Sigur Ros's ( ), Type O Negative's Bloody Kisses, Modest Mouse's Moon and Antartica, and Flaming Lip's Soft Bulletin). The best instance has been ( ), definitely, then Bloody Kisses. the other two are good, but i dont listen to them that often.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I need to hear some of the band's/artist's songs before i buy any of their CDs. I did once buy a record (not a CD, this was a LONG time ago) without hearing anything from it, but i already had a couple of albums by that band anyway so i had a good idea of what the album would sound like.

  • Huevo
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    Hi Rukrym!

    I wouldn't say often but the times I have I've been super pleased. It used to be more in the past, like Sookie said, for now I do not have the money to squander due to those damn "adult" responsibilites but occasionally I'll do it for poops and giggles. Probably the best one I can think of was in London in 1989 while visiting my family when I picked up Surfer Rosa by The Pixies because it looked interesting. That one definitely was a good choice. Back then there was no internet to check albums on or really any magazines to read up on new and fresh sounds. You just had to go with your gut feeling and hope for the best.

  • Julia
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    I have. Probably not as much as I should since there's so much music I want to buy, but I have before. I got into two of my favorite bands, Muse and Interpol, this way.

    That said, I usually prefer to hear one or two of the songs that are on an album before buying it, just to be sure that I'll like something about it. Recommendations are great too, but again, I usually look up a band before buying it. Heck, once I even bought something because I loved the cover art.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Rarely.

    The last time was over the summer. I was at a record store I normally go to, and stumbled across an album by The Nitwitz called 'Dark Side of the Spoon'. I really just bought it for the cover, which looks like the dark side of the moon cover, except, instead of the triangle, there is a spoon.

    I love the album. It's a strange, funny punk album, which are some of my favorites.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.