Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Gender of city's name?
I was in the JFK airport and just noticed a banner with this:
New York welcomes HER sister cities...(a list of other cities followed).
Is New York a SHE? or that HER is used only because of that phrase "sister cities"?
My mother language is Spanish, and I just improving my English skills. In Spanish I dont find any problem, because "ciudad" is a femenine word, but English words are different. I thought city was neutral (it have no sex).
If city is feminine, are there other similar words?
can you give some examples?
So, Is it correct to replace a city's name for "it" or "she"? are both pronouns correct?
3 Answers
- innervision7576Lv 41 decade agoFavorite Answer
The pronoun "she" is sometimes used to refer to things which contain people such as countries, ships, and cars, or to refer to machines. This, however, is considered a stylistically marked, optional figure of speech. This usage is furthermore in decline and advised against by most journalistic style guides such as the Chicago Manual of Style.[8]
Edited: Yes you can absolutely refer to a city as she. You can also use the word it.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
I know what you mean, I did Span as a second language, and everything has a gender. It's not the same in English. Nouns don't have a gender, however, in some cases, instead of calling NY "it" it jsut sounds better to call it "she" you dont' have to but it's just something weird we do. But usually, if an objectis a "she", its usually cars, ships, and the sorts. As for naming something "he", a history teacher once told me submarines were referred to as "he". You don't just get sister cities, you an get sister schools, and etc... hope that explains it a little better...
- Feelin Randi?Lv 51 decade ago
In English it is customary to denote a female gender to inanimate objects (especially when it comes to men's toys such as cars, boats, golf clubs, etc).
But cities, states and nations are also "shes".
Giving this human quality to a lifeless thing is called "Personification". As you know, normally in English objects do not have gender at all (they are neutral).
In all technicality I guess you could say "he" instead it just isn't customary and flies in the face of tradition.