Why Hollywood should remake Battle Royale!?

First of all it's not a remake, because the movie will be base on manga Battle Royale. And It will be fame by fame like the movie "300". Only cut out the unnecessary part in the book.

Many fans hated the Hollywood for remake the film. My question is why?

I know the movie (Japanese version) was good...but...it doesn't have the same feeling as the book!

I mean... did you read the manga?

The action scene is like "Matrix" and "Kill Bill" style.

The Japanese make "Battle Royale" into a very interesting film, but they are lack of one thing and that's Visual Effect!

Japanese people are suck with their visual effect techniques, I mean South Korean and china has better visual effect than them.

The Japanese films change many plots that didn’t stay true to the manga. They cut out so many action scenes from the book...If you want to know what I talking about just read the manga “Battle Royale”.

So what do you think should or shouldn't remake?