Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Laura asked in Social SciencePsychology · 1 decade ago

Death of a loved one and the importance of justice as a healing tool?

I have been watching the news and seen the pain of that family from Orpington, whose son was killed in a beach accident in the Bahamas some years ago (I forget how many). The case has been dismissed for lack of evidence.

The family is distraught.

Why is a court decision so important to the healing process for bereaved people? Why is the act of naming a culprit, of placing the blame so cathartic?

I don't dispute the fact, this not a scathing query. This is purely a question of the psychology of this situation.

Update:

Rose, the question accepts that the perpetrator should be 'brought to justice'.

What it asks is why is this psychologically important.

Update 2:

Rowan, thank you. But have you noticed how some bereaved people become aggressively dependent upon the result?

Update 3:

Jean, I wonder if you are hinting at a culture of blame, that needs there to be another figure to be responsible for the death, in that way it exonerates the bereaved from any guilt, even the very normal reaction of survivor guilt?

Or is it symptomatic of the litigation culture we have developed?

Update 4:

RM, I'm a mother. Your 'waffle'(lol) struck a chord and I can only say that stories like yours makes me hold my boy tighter for longer.

What you say makes sense too. I just wondered if it's a sub-conscious survival instinct, using anger to override the pain, giving the bereaved another focus, allowing them to carry on.

Update 5:

Ditzy, that has always been my view of the matter. I once said that I hoped that I wouldn't behave in such a basic way, but now I have a child, I'm not sure that I wouldn't even if my common sense was telling me it was futile.

Update 6:

Ditzy, that has always been my view of the matter. I once said that I hoped that I wouldn't behave in such a basic way, but now I have a child, I'm not sure that I wouldn't even if my common sense was telling me it was futile.

6 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Losing a loved one hurts, no doubt. I think it's interesting though -- psychologists have done studies of families of murder victims, and the families tend to say that they want the murderer to get the death penalty, and they want to be there to watch. They truly believe that it will make the feel better and heal the pain. But, AFTER they have watched the execution, they don't actually feel better at all and often feel even worse. I think it's just so painful to lose a loved one that NOTHING will make it go away except lots and lots of time. I guess we think that an eye for an eye will make us feel better, but it doesn't really.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    speaking from experiance as i have lost a child, the initial reaction is to blame someone, i think it is a natural reaction not only to justify your loss but also the minds way of searching for a way of undoing the damage. which of course wont happen but with such traumatic loss it is natural to not believe what has happened. you then blame yourself.

    people think finding that reason will bring closure even revenge , for instance the driver of the boat who didnt do

    anything wrong was still in control of that boat and therefore took the childs life, this for a parent is the only way to cope with the greiving and maybe they think they will feel better if a punishment for their childs death could be brought, i am probably waffling ,all i know for sure is losing a child is the single most painfull traumatic heart smashing thing that can happen to a mother or father, the range of emotions are immense, denial , anger, dibeleif, rage, fear, self pity, and many more. sorry if ths didnt make sense, but it is so difficult to put into words.

    the pain of my loss has ever gone away, it has been 7 years, time doesnt heal it, it only helps you to cope better with it

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I think in many cases it gives the family some sort of closure for an incident such as that.Perhaps also, the thought that the death of your loved one means that other lives will not be at risk in the same way in future, gives the feeling of purpose to the loved one's life.

  • 1 decade ago

    Using Justice system is not to heal your self. It is to make sure that this sort of things does not happen to anyone else. Well, I feel sorry for that family but there is nothing you can do about it you know, unless THEY step up and bring that person to justice four community's good.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    People now tend to look to blame something or someone for what has happened in their lives,and will go to extraordinary lengths to get a result in which they can find comfort.

    Source(s): Yes.
  • i thought it was a case of bringing the perpatrator to justice

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.