The next round: One album will be erased from music history and memories, the other will be saved...?

The Beatles' Rubber Soul

Bob Dylan's The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan

Coldplay's A Rush of Blood to the Head

The Cure's Disintegration

The Doors' self-titled debut

Pink Floyd's The Dark Side of the Moon

Michael Jackson's Thriller

U2's The Joshua Tree

Interesting question.

Alright, here we go:

The Who's Quadrophenia

Bob Dylan's The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan

Coldplay's A Rush of Blood to the Head

The Cure's Disintegration

The Doors' self-titled debut

Pink Floyd's The Dark Side of the Moon

Paul McCartney & Wings' Band on the Run

The Rolling Stones' Beggars Banquet

Now, explainations: I wasn't so much into the Beatles' Rubber Soul album, so that's gone.

I didn't like Neil Young at all.

I HATE Green Day

The Cure is just a classic band, I think, and that Foo Fighter's album wasn't the best one they created.

I <3 The Doors

Now, this one was hard: Led against Pink Floyd. I <3ed all their albums, but I chose Pink Floyd because that album related to some things that were happening in my life at that point in time.

I did NOT get into Michael Jackson at all, and Paul McCartney is a legend.

U2 is not my kind of band either, it was definetely the rolling stones on that one.

Quadrophenia

The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan

A Rush of Blood to the Head

Disintegration

Transformer

Dark Side of the Moon

Band on the Run

Beggars Banquet

Led Zeppelin's Houses of the Holy Fleetwood Mac's Rumours Pink Floyd's Meddle The Beatles' Help! Nirvana's In Utero Radiohead's Kid A David Bowie's Station to Station Talking Heads' Remain in Light

I would save:

Rubber Soul

Freewheelin' Bob Dylan

A Rush of Blood to the Head

The Doors

Dark Side of the Moon

Band on the Run

Joshua Tree (although I like the Stones better)

The Who's Quadrophenia

Neil Young's Harvest

Green Day's American Idiot

Foo Fighters' The Colour and the Shape

The Doors' self-titled debut

Led Zeppelin's Led Zeppelin IV

pass

The Rolling Stones' Beggars Banquet

can we please erase coldplay completely?

edit: er, ok. sorry i asked. ;)

The Who!

Bob Dylan

oh damn...uh.. Green Day but i'd throw the cd in a corner and never listen to it

The Cure

The Doors

AHHH! I don't think it is possible to decide, but Floyd by the slimmest margin possible

Paul McCartney and Wings!

Rolling Stones

phew some of those were tricky

Who

Dylan

Coldplay

Cure

Doors

Pink Floyd

Thriller

U2

Wish I could keep the Beatles, Zep and Lou Reed and lose Coldplay, U2 and Thriller - oof

Goobye Rubber Soul, see Ya

Peace Out Dylan

Hit the road Green Day

Burn em both I don't care

Bye Transformer

Unfortunately, Goodbye Zep

MJ punting! YAY!!!

I love The Johua Tree but it's outta here!

Save:

American Idiot by Green Day (not the greatest album but it got me into rock music!)

Disintegration by The Cure

and

Thriller by Michael Jackson.