The X Factor group single tonight......?

yeah they were

i dont think whoever said "let's not make them sing it live" is forgetting that we've been listening to them sing live over the last few months - so we know what they sound like live (and what they dont sound like live)

so it was so obv that they were miming

and i didnt notice about dan or ruth till i read it on here lol

Yes, without a doubt; most of them soundd ten times better than they usually do, and Alexandra and Austin had to mime to Ruth and Daniel's solos which was hilarious as they were looking around them really nervously at that point.

Never heard GirlBand sound so good :-)

Definitely, I thought Eoghan would have been good anyway but when Laura and that other bloke came on I was suspicious, then by the time it got to Rachel I was 100% sure!!

And I didn't notice Daniel and Ruth were missing until I read this either!

Yea, suppose it harmonized it better though!

Still want to know where the feck Daniel and Ruth were

I think so, it sounded pretty perfect. I guess they did it to avoid mistakes since it was such a big thing and very organinsed. Same really, but I enjoyed the song.

I wondered that too!!!