Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Tom K
Lv 6
Tom K asked in Science & MathematicsAgriculture · 1 decade ago

How can I increase the ion exchange equivalence of a blended soil?

There is a regulatory minimum of 1.0 cation exchange equivalents per kilogram of soil for the particular use at issue. Obviously, the soil to be used is not meeting this standard.

I need some idea of possible amendments to raise this number and how much these amendments will affect it. I can figure equivalents from a pure ion standpoint, but who can add pure ions?

Lime, Portland cement and powdered or crushed limestone are the most readily available substances I can think of but I don't know how to judge how much of an effect these will have if applied at particular weight per kilogram of existing soil.

Does anyone have a general rule or specific suggestion?

Update:

Both are excellent and correct answers, as the information found from Clemson and Cornell Universities has shown.

Thank you both and how do I give both a best answer? You deserve it.

Update 2:

All answers were correct, but Patrick D's is the most applicable to this situation. I have had the opportunity in this to learn more about CECs than I could imagine and I still have a way to go.

Thank you all.

4 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Lime will not add to the CEC equiv. of your soil. The only product that I can think of that can add CEC is humic acid. Humates are huge, highly complex organic molecules with many negatively charged side groups. This is why they have a CEC around 500 meq/ 100g. This is about 10x CEC of the most fertile soil.

    As far as a rate, that would depend on your application. Is this a field or containers? The product will have directions on the label.

    Humic acid is available at fertilizer retailers and hydroponic shops. It should contain at least 5% humic acids by weight.

    Google humic acid to learn more.

  • 1 decade ago

    Well you add clay or you add organic material.

    Clays vary a lot, but the CEC of different clays is pretty well worked out.

    Organic material is more variable but has a lot of CEC.

    Are you just taking the equivalent from tables or are you testing the soil? If testing are you using the tests that actually measure the CEC or are they simply adding up the cations to get the number?

    I'm a bit nervous because you are mentioning many different calcium products for changing the CEC and they do not change the CEC at all, but what they do do is change the results of some tests used for CEC measurement. For instance as they raise the pH, the are also raising the base saturation. When the lab removes the cations and adds them together, they will get a higher number and thus probably report a higher CEC. Even calcium just sitting in the soil will get dissolved when the lab is testing and it will be reported as CEC.

    So add clay or add organic material and you should be fine.

    Marv

  • 1 decade ago

    If your soil is primarily sand or silt, it can be impractical to raise its cation exchange capacity other than by adding organic material or clay. in effect the first step in your process is to abandon the attempt to do this with sandy soil. Those sandy soils are ok for some things but not your purpose.

    A high clay content will have that cation exchange capacity, even a silty clay. But even a clay soil will be better with a lot of organic matter. A compost pile has a lot of cation exchange capacity.

  • oehler
    Lv 4
    4 years ago

    we are dealing with this appropriate now. We had a kitten that had 5 kittens, so the mummy is somewhat 5 or 6 months older than her muddle. alongside with the two person cats, we've 7 cats. they're now 4 months previous, and we are finding for residences for the kittens. it is not straight forward because of fact we've been unsuccessful in different tries to place the cats. The worst is that our community animal administration shield refuses to handle the stray cat subject in our community. as a effect, we've a cat inhabitants explosion. The shield costs $5 to take pets in purely, yet in addition they sell cats to the community analyze centers for $15. the mummy (a feral cat we had to put in the pound because of fact she is unadoptable - she would be in a position to no longer use the muddle container constantly). I shudder to think of roughly what i visit do if we can't locate someplace for the kittens we can't shop. we can't manage to pay for to maintain each and all of the cats and our house is a few distance too small for this many cats.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.