Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

views on dog breeding...i asked this a minute ago but it put it in birds even though i sed put it in dogs..?

Views on breeding?...what do you think?

I have noticed a definate view on breeding on this site. And 9 times out of ten i agree with the things people are saying. I understand that BYB's and puppy mills are a big problem in America and i know that there are many dogs looking for homes all over the world. But i would like to see what the views are on this.

I live in England and i own a 14month old Smooth Collie. They are on the Native Vulnerable breeds list as less than 300 pups are registered each year. last year 63 pups were registered in Britain. My collie is due for a hip and eye scoring too see if she is healthy enough to breed. She has over 30 champions in her 5 generstion pedigree. She has been placed at every championship show she has been to. And has qualified for Crufts 2009 multiple times. She has won in her class and the last show she went to she got placed in every class she was in (i put her in all the ***** classes she was eligable for, to get her practised for indoor showing) Even Open *****. She got a first a second and 2 thirds. She is bred out of the top kennels in the country and one of the leading kennels in the world. Assuming she gets good results from her hip and eye scores she will be bred from next year or the year after. And i have 3 studs lined up all of which are from the two top kennels and all of which have qualified for cruft on a life time basis.

So, out of interest, do you think it is right for me to breed from my dog?

Update:

I have many mentors within the breed. My dogs breeders have been breeding smooth collies for over 40years.

And to ease your minds...no i am not out for a quick buck and if i was i wouldnt breed dogs. If you do it properly then there's about £5 left at the end for a cup of coffee and a toy for my dog.

Im interested in bettering the breed and producing healthy dual pupose dogs. Bee (my dog) is starting agiity after the new year. Her uncle is the only dog in britain (of any breed) to hold a breed and agility title. So i know smooth collies are capabe.

Update 2:

Dancing with woofs - Thank you for the compliment to 'us brits' although i must assure you there are some black sheep amongst us that i would love to get my hands on one day...as to the sleeping outside comment...I KNOW...u americans are weird sometimes (gta love ya though) i know a few people that make there dogs sleep outside but there in kennels or outhouses (does this count as outside?) not just chained up. My welsh collie sleeps in my bed =).

15 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I'm not a breeder but if I was looking to buy a puppy then you would be the kind of person I would hope to find. I am assuming that as your dog is showing so well you have a vested interest in the breed, have a wide knowledge of the breed standard and are taking steps to ensure the health and compatibility of the parent dogs and therefore any subsequent puppies. If I was looking to buy you would be able to advise me about the breed itself and ensure I had realistic expectations. I use BYB not to indicate someone who breeds from their home but as a term to identify people who irresponsibly churn out litter after litter with no regard for the health of the dogs nor care about the families they are going to, they are only in it for what money they can make. My Rough Collie and my Shih Tzu were bred from family homes but we checked them out thoroughly and were satisfied that as breed club members, regulars on the show circuit, etc. they had the best interest of the dogs at heart and we were grilled to within an inch of our lives about what we could offer the dog, what our expectations were, etc. and we weren't offered a puppy until they were satisfied that we could give the dogs the best possible homes. In short if they didn't like us and think the dogs would be as well cared for by us as they were with the breeders then we weren't getting a puppy and that is something I am encouraged by. If a breeder doesn't care more about the puppy than the money I'd automatically look for someone else.

  • 1 decade ago

    Absolutely - just make sure you have one of your mentors in the breed help you pick out which stud balances out your bltch, and make VERY sure you have good info on their health backgrounds.

    The one problem with all that showing is the botteneck effect created when everyone trundles off to breed to the same few dogs, and the gene pool gets so small you 'find' all the genetic flaws.

    Your dog is a good example of one that should be bred, so the breed is preserved. Good luck!

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    As long as your not a backyard breeder that is just looking to make a few dollars. Your dog is a show dog and has show dog lines. I still dont agree with breeding when there are tons of dogs in need of homes out there. But i do believe in bettering the breed, and the qualities of the breed.

  • 1 decade ago

    I think it would be fine for you to breed your dog,as long as you are willing to take back any pups that may not be wanted,at any time in their lives.But you are being a responsible breeder by doing all of the proper health testing and showing your dog. I also tend to think that you Brits take better care of your dogs and are much more careful when it comes to breeding than people in the US.My British friends cannot believe that people here actually chain their dogs to doghouses and make them live outside!

  • 1 decade ago

    OK this is my view....

    A dog that should be bred...both the Sire & Dam should meet the following qualifications

    Is shown/worked & Championed before breeding

    Is tested OFA, Pen Hipp, temper ect....

    Has good bloodline & Ch's at least 4-5 Generations back

    Registered but that is obvious

    Is a min. age of 2 yrs old

    I could go on this is just the basics

    I think any dog without a positive pedigree should never ever be bred but instead should be spayed/nuetered

    Source(s): I own & run a rescue
  • You have obviously done your research on your dog, and you've been active in showing her to be certain that she's a prime specimen. Qualifying for Crufts 2009 multiple times is something to be congratulated for!

    Based on the information you've provided, I'd say that yes, it's right for you to breed her.

  • 1 decade ago

    Meet up with a dog breeder who breeds a similar breed. Talk to them. See what they do. Ask them questions. Don't do this alone. Have a mentor you can question. I think that you do have a good dog. Keep showing her and work on her.

    Source(s): I gave you a star!
  • Kate M
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    As long as you have a good breeding mentor, she passes her hip and eye tests and you wait until she is 2 years old, then sure. She seems like a great dog and a good representation of her breed.

  • ?
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    as quickly as I worked for a vet. the 1st day i became teching I had to help positioned down 3 gray hounds. Sooo unhappy. some situations while the canine is so a techniques long gone or perhaps dehydrated it incredibly is not worry-free to detect a vein. it is my wager as to why the vet ought to not detect a vein. No is don't have been loose. yet they might desire to have a minimum of given you a chit. i'm sorry on your loss.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    You sound like a responsible person. Have you talked to the breeder your bi**h came from? they could give you valuable information on the bloodlines and help you pick the best stud for producing the best puppies. You want to produce the best you can, and continue to show her to get her championship.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.