Should I offer this fantasy baseball trade?

1) Do you think he'll take this

2) If he does, is it a good deal for me?

3) Could I even possibly get away with offering Salty? (doubt it)

5 X 5 roto, 12 teams, 23 man rosters

He's clearly a bit short on pitching...

I give:

Zack Greinke

Mike Napoli

I get:

Matt Wieters

Max Scherzer

My roster:

C

Mike Napoli

(LAA - C)

C

Jarrod Saltalamacchia

(Tex - C)

1B

Prince Fielder

(Mil - 1B)

2B

Chone Figgins

(LAA - 2B,3B)

3B

David Wright

(NYM - 3B)

SS

Stephen Drew

(Ari - SS)

CI

Edwin Encarnación

(Cin - 3B)

MI

Ryan Theriot

(ChC - SS)

OF

Jason Bay

(Bos - OF)

OF

Álex Ríos

(Tor - OF)

OF

Conor Jackson

(Ari - 1B,OF)

OF

Denard Span

(Min - OF)

OF

Adam Lind

(Tor - OF)

Util

Casey Kotchman

(Atl - 1B)

BN

Ryan Church

(NYM - OF)

BN

Casey Blake

(LAD - 1B,3B)

BN

Ryan Spilborghs

(Col - OF)

P

Roy Halladay

(Tor - P)

P

Félix Hernández

(Sea - P)

P

Roy Oswalt

(Hou - P)

P

B.J. Ryan

(Tor - P)

P

Zack Greinke

(KC - P)

P

Matt Lindstrom

(Fla - P)

P

Frank Francisco

(Tex - P)

P

Ubaldo Jiménez

(Col - P)

P

Fernando Rodney

(Det - P)

BN

Grant Balfour

(TB - P)

BN

Jeremy Guthrie

(Bal - P)

BN

Sean Gallagher

(Oak - P)

His team:

C

Matt Wieters

(Bal - C) NA

C

Jorge Posada

(NYY - C) DL

1B

Ryan Howard

(Phi - 1B)

2B

Robinson Canó

(NYY - 2B)

3B

Hank Blalock

(Tex - 1B,3B)

SS

Troy Tulowitzki

(Col - SS)

CI

Mark Reynolds

(Ari - 3B)

MI

Rafael Furcal

(LAD - SS)

OF

Matt Holliday

(Oak - OF)

OF

Jacoby Ellsbury

(Bos - OF)

OF

Bobby Abreu

(LAA - OF)

OF

Torii Hunter

(LAA - OF)

OF

Justin Upton

(Ari - OF)

Util

Carlos Gómez

(Min - OF)

BN

Ian Stewart

(Col - 2B,3B)

BN

Travis Hafner

(Cle - Util)

BN

Gary Sheffield

(Det - OF)

BN

Josh Fields

(CWS - 3B)

P

Johan Santana

(NYM - P)

P

Brian Fuentes

(LAA - P)

P

Huston Street

(Col - P)

P

Max Scherzer

(Ari - P)

P

Brandon Morrow

(Sea - P)

P

John Maine

(NYM - P)

P

Wandy Rodríguez

(Hou - P)

P

Dan Wheeler

(TB - P)

P

Scot Shields

(LAA - P)

BN

J.J. Putz

(NYM - P)

BN

Mike Adams

(SD - P)