Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

sociology help about social positions...what are they?

Okay this is the question I have to answer....

Self-concept emerges from a person’s unique intersection of social positions such as class, gender, race, religion, sexuality, age, and so forth. consider which aspects of your social position are more or less “central” and more or less “marginal.” What impact might your specific position have had on your interactions and experiences?

MY QUESTION FOR YOU IS... considering the examples given can I use things like parent/mother or student as being social positions...to me they are but not in the same way that the examples are...do you think she is only meaning those basic identifying pieces of information?

although I would like to be able to say that my religion is central, it does not guide my actions the way it should. These things just don't, my actions are guided by my status as a mother, wife, and college student...To be honest the semester is almost over and I am getting kind of sick of writing about who I am and life examples of all of these topics.

If you want to write how you would answer the above question...it would be interesting as well. Obviously this isn't something that I could just copy from someone else because it is a personal type question.

Update:

don't you think you should site wiki on that? honestly....my question was since the examples given were race, sex, sexuality, religion do you think that using parent, student, wife etc... would be okay...I know what wikipedia has to say on the subject.

Update 2:

okay so I figured out the answer for anyone that might stumble upon this question needing to know.

those basic race, sex, class etc... are what counts in this aspect. The central ones are the ones that are hegemonic--'the norm' so white, male, protestant, heterosexual, middle class are the hegemonic or central positions. The marginal positions are anything that is stigmatized so black, female, Catholic, homosexual, lower class, etc....

2 Answers

Relevance
  • radish
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Yes, your choice of how to interpret 'social positions' is not only valid but very insightful.

    Over the past 35 years there has been a lot of sociological research into the ways that gender and class (and ethnicity) intersect to create our social positions in both paid work and study in the public sphere and the unpaid work of housework and caring.

    One especially interesting set of analysies developed in the 1980s in the field of social policy around the concepts of;

    'caring'

    'coping'

    'community'

    showing how these terms were 'weasel words' hiding and glossing over the extensive work and the tensions of this contradictory social positions -wife/mother/student/worker.

    This research has included

    -the more philosophical and historical aspects of sociology to analyse 'how we got where we are now'

    -as welll as many current forms of research to understand how the lives of people occupying the complex position of being, at the same time, wife/mother/student/ worker are so contradictory, complex and often stress laden.

    --and then to ask why, before the 1960s, these complex social positions were so often the 'hidden' in sociology.

    Go for it. Anne Oakley would be proud.

    nb the question did ask you to examine the relationships between these positions so I'm sure its not ony going to be right for you but its also what your lecturer is looking for.

    ps Since then there has been some very interesting work looking at the same complexities for men and masculinity.

    pps the two perspectives, funtionalism and conflict thoery tend to use different concepts on this . My answer above is from conflict theory ..different terms used, thus different research questions asked and different interpretations;

    Functionalism:social position/social role/ role conflict(but the underlying reasons for this conflict not examined)

    Conflict theory:historical development of the modern family/ 'contradiction '(not from the roles themselves, but from the underlying and often unspoken social rules about the separation of public and domestic spheres)/ social construction of unpaid caring work/economic invisiblility of housework/family-work life balance/

    Source(s): Anne Oakley 'Housewife' the 'Sociology of Housework'. Janet Finch and Dulcie Groves ''A Labour of Love; Women, Work and Caring' RW Connell 'Masculinities' Bettina Cass 'Population Policies and Families Policies: State Construction of Domestic Life' Hilary Graham 'Coping : or how mothers are seen and not heard' Susan Moller Okin 'Women in Western Political Thought' Genevieve Lloyd 'The Man of Reason:' Anna Yeatman 'Women, Domestic Life and Sociology nb these are all 20 or more years old now but their analyses still have relevance.
  • srura
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    Social position is the position of an individual in a given society and culture. A given position (for example, the occupation of priest) may belong to many individuals. Social position influences social status. One can have several social positions, but only one social status.

    Social positions an individual may hold fall into the categories of occupation (medical doctor, academic lecturer), profession (member of associations and organisations), family (parent, sibling, etc.), hobby (member of various clubs and organisations), among others. An individual is likely to create a personal hierarchy of such positions, where one will be a central position while the rest are perhiperal positions.

    Social positions are visible if they require an individual to wear a uniform or some other kind of identifying mark. Often individual clothes or other attributes will advertise what social position one has at the moment. Non-visible social positions are called hidden. A position that is deemed the most important to given individual is called central, others are peripheral. If a sequence of positions is required to obtain a given position, it can be defined as a career, and change of position in this context is a promotion or demotion. Some social positions may make it easier for a given person to obtain others; in other cases, some positions may be restricted based to individuals meeting specific criteria.

    Social position together with social role determines individual's place in the social environment and social organisation. A group of social positions will create a social class and a social circle.

    A social conflict caused by interference between social positions is called a position conflict.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.