Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Do you think that jokes about religion make religion lose its power...?

...or does the fact that a religion is starting to have less influence on people mean somebody can get away with making a joke?

If we take the Abrahamic religions as an example:

- Eddie Izzard is a British comedian. He makes fun of the Church of England in a very silly way, such as his 'cake or death' sketch. In England, we're not very religious, and nobody takes offence.

- A while back (I'm sure you all remember) a newspaper in Europe printed a cartoon of Muhammed, and some Muslims got very angry, as their religion does not approve of images of him. There were protests, and things got blown out of proportion. Islam is currently having a hard time because of extremists like the Taliban.

Do you think that a faith with lots of followers, which is running theocracies or trying to get power in governments, can be brought down a little by humour? Or do you think that it would have to lose power and become 'harmless' enough (for want of a better word) to be laughed at, and therefore any jokes would be a result of it being safe enough to joke?

Perhaps it depends on the style of humour. Satire, or angry, sarcastic humour (George Carlin or Bill Hicks, maybe) is likely to provoke a different reaction to something like the British sitcom The Vicar of Dibley, which is as much about the strange people living in a country village as it is about their new female vicar.

Of course, there is a difference between picking on people with a particular faith and being humourous, and I don't condone bullying at all. But what do you guys think?

There's a lot of questions there, I look forward to your answers. Go go go!

Update:

I did say in the question that I was talking about religion when it becomes a political entity as well as a spiritual one. It was buried pretty deep so some of you may have missed it. In short, what I meant was: Does humour (including the style and intention of that humour) have an effect on how much influence religion has on other aspects of society?

Update 2:

@Terryhoare- do you think people are more likely to accept humour about their religion if they can laugh at themselves? You mentioned Catholics, do you think that maybe those who see the silly side of it like they do with other things in life get less offended by others?

9 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    It depends what you mean by power, and it depends what jokes.

    In secular societies, such as the UK, religion doesn't have much power these days - it's just one of the components of a diverse society, and is generally respected. The humour tends to be more of the Dibley type - using a religious setting rather than satire.

    However, in relatively recent times the churches had much more power and were seen to be trying to control people, including non-believers. At that time satire was more important as a way of ridiculing such attitudes. Monty Python's "Life of Brian" was a breakthrough work, as it poked fun at Christianity, as well as many other aspects of life.

    This caused uproar amongst the churches, many of whom regarded it as blasphemous and tried to get it banned. For most people, however, it was just regarded as bitingly funny, as it tapped into a popular vein of dissatisfaction with the churches' interference in politics and people's lives.

    More recently "Father Ted" has had a similar role in the gradual but steady secularisation of Ireland south of the border. Satire tends to be used when there is some sort of unfairness or unacceptable situation to be resisted, as it can tap into the popular psyche more than reasoned argument. Hence its continuing role ridiculing British politics, with programmes like "Have I got News for You".

    In the most oppressive days of communist domination of central Europe, telling jokes about the regimes could attract significant jail sentences, as ridicule was the one thing that these dictatorships really could not stand. It was one of the major methods of psychological resistance to the system, as it often made a mockery of the official propaganda. It was like a viral symbol of disbelief.

    There are still societies where religion tries to control people, and this is where satire still has a role, as well as other forms of humour. Thus humour tends to be more gentle when there isn't anything to be resisted, and more satirical and biting when there is.

    Edit:

    You're right about humour having a role more than just making people laugh. It can prick the bubble of pomposity and arrogance, both at a state/theocratic level, and also by letting people lighten up about their own religion. If people can laugh at their own ideas, they're likely to be more secure with them and less likely to beat up others about them.

  • 1 decade ago

    Not at all!. Catholicism has been around for 2000 years and criticized, laughed at, spat at, accused, defamed, persecuted, martyred.; the only thing that loses power is the "entertainer" and those who use it for their own selfish purposes. They who claim a privilege which does not exist, to make fun of something sacred to others defame themselves; they certainly are not favored amongst the thousands of Catholics and possibly other Christians; so who loses?.

    The Christian Faith is empowered by supernatural factors and the holiness of worthy men and women who contribute to society.If Christianity were a social institution, no doubt it would lose power, fortunately it does not have to depend entirely on the shifting currents of an era nor the self-opinionated humor opinion of comedians.

    Moreover, in the case of Catholicism, It just keeps going on. Now that's 'funny', isn't it? However, not all humor is meant to be offensive, this Catholics can take and in fact use.They don't feel less empowered.

    Source(s): Experience
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I don't think jokes themselves make religion lose it's power, but I do think people who argue against the content of a joke make religion lose some of it's power.

    People who try and argue against a JOKE really make themselves seem silly, and by extension their religion. After all it is a Joke and by definition is not meant to be serious. I'll take for example the Muslim cartoon you mention. If they didn't raise such a fuss about it, no one would have thought twice about it, but because they complained so much about a cartoon, more cartoons came about parodying the whole issue. Who can really take seriously a religion that involves rioting against a cartoon?

    I'll admit to not really knowing much about religion myself. I personally don't believe in religion, mostly because of things like that, where religious people can't tolerate other's views, not even mild jokes. I do believe in a higher power but disagree with the way most people go about showing their belief.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Faith in religion is only as strong/faithful as the people want it to be. Also everyone has there own opinion, there is no need to compare your religious life with someone else...

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    hi

    not at all. whats life without poking some fun,and remember life is 2 short not 2 have fun jimbo

    Source(s): having a fun life
  • 1 decade ago

    every since tom cruise became the posterboy/laughing stock of Scientology i think religion has lost most of it's credibility

  • mimjoy
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    no it can not change the truth it just means people are not so angry about a joke islam can not take a joke obviously.

  • Nothing can change the power and majesty of the sovereign God.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    No

    But it shows it' s weak sides

    Which there are many

    And subsequently, it shows, what religion is REALLY about

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.