Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Atheism in Israel ? A few questions to the Israeli citizens ?

Hi, please help me with this survey, im doing a research about Atheism and the treatment of Atheists in the middle astern countries

1 - If a member of your family (brother, sister, father...etc) said that he converted to atheism, you will:

A. Try to talk him out of it.

B. Never talk to him again.

C. Ignore it, religious views doesn't affect your relationships.

D. Something els (please mention it)

2- If you were an Israeli Atheist, you would:

A. Hide your thoughts so you won't lose friends.

B. Tell only the close friends and family members

C. Tell everyone about it, your society is fine with it

D. Other. (please mention it)

3- Would you ever elect an Atheist president ?

4- What first comes to your mind when hear the word "Atheist" ?

5- Why do you think some people chose not to believe in God ?

Thanks in advance.

10 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    There are indeed.

    The Jews are for Israel.

    The Christians are for Israel.

    The atheists are for Israel.

    The Bahais are for Israel.

    The Japanese are for Israel.

    The Druse are for Israel.

    That's just for a start.

    The Muslims are against Israel. Their religion gives them no choice.

    The Muslims are also against their fellow Arabs. Reports about the repression of Hamas opponents were obtained from Palestinians detained by the IDF during Operation Cast Lead. For example, Hamas operative Nawaf Faisal Atar, a resident of Al-Atatra who was detained on January 11, said that Gazans who dared to oppose Hamas were shot in the legs [as corroborated by the Amnesty report]. He said that Gazans were afraid to oppose Hamas because its operatives did not hesitate to call people Israeli collaborators and execute them.

    Hamad Fajar Saleh, a resident of Jabaliya, who was detained on January 12, said that in 2007 Hamas operatives shot and killed his brother, who had guarded the house of the Palestinian Authority employee responsible for internal security. He also said that Hamas prevented people affiliated with Fatah from getting the food and other items of humanitarian aid they were entitled to from UNRWA.

    In addition, the media (especially those affiliated with Fatah) issued similar reports. For example, during Operation Cast Lead a motorcyclist was reported to have shot and killed a Palestinian in Gaza who had been suspected of collaborating with Israel and who escaped from the detention facility attacked by the Israeli Air Force. According to eye witnesses, the victim was shot three times in the head and chest.

    .

    Source(s): Reuters, January 4, 2009
  • 5 years ago

    For two main reasons, neither having to do with Apartheid: (QUICK NOTE: Druze Arabs are drafted into the IDF, so your claim isn't entirely accurate.) -Firstly, this way, Israeli Arabs are not forced into situations where they may have to fight, and even kill, their Arab cousins. -Secondly, despite being Israeli citizens, many Arab-Israelis are hostile to the country, and wouldn't hesitate to turn over information they learn from the IDF to its enemies (tactics, training, troop positions, etc.) However, if they so choose, Arabs can serve, though they are not legally compelled. Often however, Arabs who do join the IDF are harassed by their fellow Arabs and therefore choose to remain anonymous when giving interviews, etc. I'm not quite sure what about this system suggests that Israel is an Apartheid country.

  • 1 decade ago

    1 c 2 I am an Israeli and could not conceive being one 3 none of our prime ministers or presidents were atheists I would not elect one 4 a non believer 5 I don't know when we look at the beauty of nature etc how can we not believe

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Nobody can answer that simply. If the family is religious and the male or female was raised that way, it may be shocking to them. Other families are more moderate or secular and it may not bother them. Some people may just wish to join a non-Orthodox version of Judaism or they are privately spiritual or just ethnically, culturally Jewish, so they have a different viewpoint. It is a matter of personal choice, like marriage, career matters, divorce, children, travel, living arrangements and so on.

    Source(s): On Muslims being against Israel: Most Palestinians, around seventy percent, want a two-state solution. The Muslims are not against Judaism and Jews, but Zionism. One should not equate Judaism with Zionism. Not all Jews are Zionists. In Zionism, there are religious, cultural, ethnic and political viewpoints. Most Muslims now accept Israel's existence as a Jewish state. Very few forward a one-state solution with a right of return for Palestinians into Israel. What they want is a viable Palestinian state with compensation for both sides, building of houses for refugees with a chance at citizenship and resettlement in Palestine/Jordan, the removal of all settlements past the '49 border and the sharing of Jerusalem with East Jerusalem as a Palestinian capital. They want an end to the occupation, military aid for Israel and removal of settlements at the beginning of any peace-oriented negotiations, because they see nothing coming to them in terms of opportunity and still watch as massacres occur against Gazans, West Bank residents and the Lebanese. They oppose Israeli military policy. These people are not stupid, biased and uninformed: they recognize the reality of the situation. As they watch Chechens lose their country and become refugees and face genocide, the illegal invasion and occupation of Afghanistan by NATO-backed forces and the destruction of Iraq (a non-threatening moderate country where Shi'ah and Sunni Muslims coexisted peacefully with Christians), they ask themselves why America is surprised by suicide bombings and extremism, not that they favor it or support it, but nobody can have a discussion of political extremism in the Middle East without looking at American foreign policy and Western colonialism. And then people blame Islam, as if all Muslims were radical. They never look at the economic, cultural, historical and political background of certain countries. I firmly believe there will be more protest and intifadas until these policies change, even if I think that intifadas are not the best way to solve the problem. I certainly do not condone terrorism which is a problem that must be stamped out, but not through collective punishment of the Palestinian people.
  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    I think a key point is being missed here:

    Because Israel is a *democracy* ALL Israelis are able to live, and worship - or not worship! - as they please.

    And as 'Boomerang' rightly noted, one can be a Jewish Atheist, because Judaism also involves a complex moral structure that one can embrace. Also, a Jew only becomes an EX Jew IF they adopt ANOTHER FAITH. ***Any*** other faith.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Since at least 80% of so-called "Israelis' are hard-core atheists none of your sub-questions really apply,unless specifically addressed to actual practicing Jews,which would exclude most Zionists.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    There's no such thing as "converting to atheism" because atheism is not a religion but rather the rejection of the idea of deities.

    Judaism is not only about believing in God, but also contains a great deal of ethics. Some branches in Judaism centralize around the ethics and moral heritage of Judaism, and not around the belief in God.

    In other words - it's perfectly acceptable for a Jewish person not to be an atheist.

    For the rest of the answer, I'll refer "conversion to atheism" to "a Jewish person who rejects the idea of God".

    1 - C

    2 - C

    3 - Sure

    4 - Rational

    5 - Because the concept lost most of its purpose in the modern age.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    The vast majority of so-called Israelis are atheists or what they euphemistically call "secular Jews". Believe me there is no problem with atheists in the alleged Judenstatte. It was founded by atheists and it has always been governed by atheists. So far as I know they have never elected a practicing Jew as Prime Minister. It is a sad irony that the Holy Land of Christianity and Islam should come under the iron heel of six million Russian atheists.

  • 1 decade ago

    I don't care what faith it is if you have raised children you have addressed this in your life.

    You can lead a friend to learn but you can't force your beliefs on anyone.

    Individual choice . Just be there to let God use you when the time comes.

    I have never seen any group more interested in shouting out their stand than atheist. For the most part they love to feel superior for having no beliefs at all.

    Atheist in politics is old news. I rather have a crooked atheist politician that will give the people what they want than any Muslim at any time.

    They don't want to put in the time or energy to learn the differences of opinion and quickly cling to the path of less resistance.

    How can you not believe in something you don't know the first thing about?

  • 1 decade ago

    1. A if they're willing to talk about it, if not I'll leave em alone.

    2. C

    3. Presidents don't often tell us if they're Atheist or not, we vote for who we think is good for the country.

    I would of course prefer a president that isn't an Atheist, after all, he is supposed to be representing the Jewish state.

    4. Nothing really.

    5. That's something we can discuss for hours.

    You're welcome

    Edit - 25% of Israelis are NOT Jewish but just to clarify something, Over 80% of Jewish Israelis are NOT atheists! Most of them keep kosher at least to some extent, 99% celebrate Jewish holidays.

    Being secular does NOT mean you're an Atheist!

    Most of what people consider secular are people who don't keep Shabbes, dress however they want and go clubbing.

    Most of these people DO in fact believe God.

    They won't keep Shabbes because it's fun to go out Friday night, they won't be 100% kosher(there are many kosher laws that people are not aware about) but they will not have non kosher meat, they will not have cheeseburgers, they WILL celebrate Jewish holidays, they will NOT eat bread on Passover and they WILL fast on Yom Kippur(very few people don't fast on this holiday - wonder why?)

    These people are NOT Atheists.

    There ARE Atheistic Jewish Israelis, but statistically they are very few. Claiming a secular Jew is an Atheist is like claiming that Muslims that drink alcohol are Atheist.

    I don't know about the rest of the middle eats but in Israel they drink and they drink a lot but they will still pray to Allah(God).

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.