Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Atheists - what do you get from browsing the religion questions on YA?
This is not an attack... I'm not some christian trying to incite a debate. Nor am I an atheist trying to rally the troops. I don't normally hang out on the religious forums myself, but a few of my friends do. I was browsing their questions and answers and noticed that there are a lot of atheists answering questions... questions of faith. I don't see any problem with you browsing there, but I don't understand WHY you are there. If you don't believe in religion... then, why hang out and answers religious questions?
That seems almost counter productive... hanging out in a forum designed for something you don't believe in. If you don't believe in god or buddha or santa claus or superman or whatever, why do you waste your time being purposefully rude and indignant to people who've done nothing to you and have legitimate questions about their faith?
Unless that is the only reason you are there, to try and upset people and feel good about yourself. All it seems like it's done; from an outsider perspective, is create a sort of... YA war between the believers and non-believers... but to what end exactly? The pleasure of trying to hurt people? Why ask something as derogatory as what page of the bible would you wipe your *** with? Is that REALLY necessary?
Again, this isn't an attack, only an observation and a question. I truly, honestly do not understand what it is you get from sitting on YA answers being hateful and prejudice to people. You seem more like a hate group than reasonable, down to earth people. It doesn't bother you that you've reduced yourselves to status of black panthers or the kkk or nazi germany with hateful rhetoric? Don't get me wrong, we ALL know about the crusades and failings of christians. They've even admitted those.
I know this question will more than likely get deleted, because that's what normally happens with real, honest questions on YA with a group that doesn't want their stance questioned. The irony is that, the most vile questions asked by atheists remain up because while they disagree with you, the 'believer' types allow you to speak your mind without trying to clamp it. I know to me that looks like someone treating you fairly and not getting any respect in return... so maybe you can correct me with what is really happening if I'm missing something. Thank you in advance.
so far, most of the answers are predictable.
thank you mr samsa for being a lone voice sensibility.
thank you lisa for reinvigorating my faith in the public education system.
thanks ikari... that was an awesome answer.
20 Answers
- Anonymous1 decade agoFavorite Answer
I see your point, but for every immature atheist answer about wiping your *** with a bible, there is an immature theist answer about atheists burning in hell.
I can't speak for anyone else other than myself, but I am here because I am genuinely intrigued by what other people believe and why they believe it. I am interested by the concept of belief. The sign on the door doesn't say you have to HAVE a religion to discuss things here. I can be interested in religion and spirituality without being religious.
Also, I like to serve as a counterpoint to certain arguments. Otherwise the other side would be woefullymisrepresentedd. In order for true discussion and debate, there should be a point and a counterpoint.
Now, I understand that there are a lot of people who troll, or post immature or downright offensive answers to get a rise out of people, but those people fall on both sides. They aren't all atheists, theyaren'tt all believers.
When I answer questions, I come in at the same level that the questioner is. If the questioner is fired up and offensive, I might use stronger language to get my point across, but that doesn't mean I dont respect their right to air their opinion. If the asker is more up for a calmer more rational discussion, that's fine too.
At the end of the day, what I get from browsing YA? is a greater understanding of the different types of believers out there. I learn a lot. I learn a lot about religion and faith, even though I myself have none. It's not a bad thing, it's just a way to share views.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Because it makes one feel superior. That's a pretty big part of our culture at present. Also, some people genuinely want to show people how to be more rational. There's often a combination of the two. And because hanging around there makes them feel intellectually superior, it takes their mind off of how irrational they themselves are being in other areas of their life that don't involve religion, for some atheists but not all. The areas of their lives in which they may be irrational could be anything from their personal relationships to politics to not wanting to have their physics theory proved wrong, etc. I'm an atheist and I don't spend very much time in the Religion and Spirituality section.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Because absence of religious belief is an aspect of religion & spirituality that's worth discussing. My views on religion are as valid and worthwhile as anyone else's.
Because those who espouse religious belief often have a tendency to want to project their particular belief out to everyone...they demand respect for their own belief, but very often refuse to give the respect they demand to anyone who doesn't agree with them. Pointing this out here can possibly lead to freedom for *all* kinds of religious thought, as the framers of our constitution intended.
I'm curious: if you don't normally "hang out" here, then on what do you base your assumption that "real, honest questions" get deleted? By your own admission you have little experience, yet you feel qualified to assume you have some great understanding of how this forum operates? Seems more than a bit disingenuous...
Peace.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
This question won't get deleted. After all, if it hasn't been deleted any of the other 48,000 times it has been asked, why would it be now?
We have interest in religion as it can affect our daily lives. We have knowledge of religion as many of us used to be religious. We don't do it to hurt people, we do it to inform people of the truth. Sorry if trying to spread facts is now a bad thing.
But really, what are you using to come to the conclusion that we're the ones who are acting like a hate group? Please show me a single instance where an atheist told a theist that they were going to be punished for eternity because of their beliefs?
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- melouofsLv 71 decade ago
I come here because I don't get it, and it's a curiosity to me. I do agree that being purposely rude is unnecessary, but I guess we're all here for different reasons, both the religious and the non-religious among the posters.
And, by the way, most religious types aren't asking quesitons about their faith either....this seems to be more of a "my ideas are better that your ideas" board, in general.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Well, I define atheism as not believing in an external/transcending being. In this definition, I am an atheist. But I am also Wiccan. Which makes me spiritual.
I like to see what other people say on matters of religion and I like to give my input.
- Mr.SamsaLv 71 decade ago
I get to answer questions, especially those questions addressed to atheists.
R&S isn't a forum "designed" for religion. It's a forum for questions and answers about the subject of religion. Obviously, I have information and opinions which are relevant to the subject, and I enjoy sharing them.
- ?Lv 71 decade ago
i came here by accident, or fate or soemthing, it just seems to be where im supposed to be in my stange in life
i was on the main page and answersd soem qs, came, left just as quickly, came back and stayed
why do i stay, the people, the atmosphere, the qs, the as, the knowledge and the learning
i woudlnt stay if i got nothing out of it
i am here to learn, not to hate on anyone,not to argue, to learn, and that i have done, and do
and its why i stay
- RevAngelaPLv 71 decade ago
A good time.
What do Christians get by prostelyzing in questions not aimed at them?
- 1 decade ago
Good question... when I asked a very similar one a few weeks back it got deleted... All I wanted was some insight... all I got was angry atheists.